Latest
What You Have to Decide Before Anybody WritesWriting It Before You Need ItCross Training Covered Everything Except the Role That Mattered MostBehind the Book: You Don’t Own Anything AnymoreBehind the Book: The Woke VirusBehind the Book: Galactic InvasionWhat’s New at The Writing King: Week of November 8, 2026Alexander Zhidkov: Decision MakingJessi Szurek: Expand Your RangeYou Don’t Own Anything AnymoreThe Budget Decided How My Department Was ShapedWhy Your Competitor’s Book Is Working and Yours Would NotWhy Are These Guys Smiling? A Business Book That Became a Wrestling MemoirPangram Wants to Decide Who Gets PublishedWhat You Have Enough Material For Right NowWhen a Book Is the Wrong ToolThe Woke VirusGalactic InvasionChatGPT Turns Four: From a Free Research Preview to GPT-6What’s New at The Writing King: Week of November 1, 2026Diwali: The Festival of Lights and the Story Behind the LampsHow Much Water and Power Does Heavy AI Use Take? I Ran My Own NumbersBad Boys: Ride or Die (2024)Vesuvius Day: The Teenager Who Wrote Down Pompeii’s Last DayAnti-Communism Week: Remembering the Writers Communism SilencedVoyager 1 One Light-Day: Fifty Years to Travel One Day of LightVellum Added an Optional AI Feature. A Pile-On Killed It in a Day.Are AI Subscriptions Losing Money? The Gym Membership Math Says NoAI Terms Every Writer Should Know, and Why Each One MattersWorking While Sick: What 24/7 On Call Cost MeHe Banned AI From His Writing Group. His Own Cover Got Called AI Slop.Who Writes the Fake Fan Mail Authors Get? Inside the Scam CompoundsSMS Appointment RemindersJoe Rockey: Ghostwriting His BookDarrell Stern: Stop Being Invisible, Become UnmissableFree BooksHow to Turn Your Expertise Into a Book People Want to Read | The Expert MethodWhat’s New at The Writing King: Week of October 25, 2026Challenger Remembrance Day: The Engineer Who Wouldn’t SignJoel Salomon: The Truth About MoneyReddit Is Putting Up a Login Wall. Wikipedia Won’t Be Far Behind.Victoria Chemko: The Body Is the First TechnologySir Patrick Stewart: A TributeA Year in the Bank: ADHD, Face Blindness and the Freedom to Walk Out | The Impossible Puzzles Show, Episode 326A Yale Economist Says We Won’t Be Missed. He Forgot the Bread Line.Walter Koenig: A TributeAI Has Paid Off Outside Tech. Apollo Is Reading the Wrong Scoreboard.I Don’t Post Bad ARC Reviews. I Send the Author a Note.The Little Red Book of Stuff That Works!Your Kids Are Your Own Fault

I Will Tell You When Your Book Idea Is Bad

TL;DR: Blunt, honest and occasionally funny is a working method. Saying the uncomfortable thing in week one is cheaper than discovering it in month five, and the humor exists because a reader who is amused is still reading. It costs me some clients and I’ve decided that’s the correct trade.

A smoke alarm that never goes off is a decoration you’ve agreed not to test.

Plenty of people in this trade work that way. The client arrives with an idea, the idea has a serious problem, and nobody mentions it because mentioning it risks the deal. The deposit gets taken and the problem surfaces in month five when it’s expensive.

I say it in week one. That’s the whole of what people mean when they describe my style as blunt, and it’s a method and not a temperament.

Why say the uncomfortable thing early?

Because the cost of a bad structural decision grows.

A book built on a premise that doesn’t hold has to be rewritten heavily, after months of interviews organized around the wrong spine and with a client who has been picturing a different book the whole time. That’s the expensive version of the same conversation, and the client pays for every month of it.

Told in week one, the same conversation takes twenty minutes and costs nothing. The client either adjusts the idea, convinces me I’m wrong, which happens, or decides to work with somebody else. All three of those outcomes are better than month five. I’ve had projects end at that conversation. Revenge memoirs are the clearest case. I won’t write one, I say so the first time the idea comes up, and every prospect who wanted one has walked away. I’d make the same call again, because a book written to hurt somebody does its worst damage to the name on the cover.

The book on this: Sell Your Books opens with the twelve copies, because a launch that went badly teaches more than one that went well.

Does bluntness mean being unpleasant?

No, and conflating them is how people justify avoiding both.

There’s a version of directness that’s really just permission to be rude, and it’s common enough in this field that clients arrive braced for it. What I’m describing is narrower: saying the accurate thing about the work, once, clearly, without decorating it. That includes my own limits. I have a package for proposals to traditional publishers, the kind that goes to an agent first. I’ve only done one, so other people may well be better at it than me. I’m honest, and then I don’t have to remember who I lied to.

The difference is what the sentence is about. Your premise doesn’t hold up, and here’s where it breaks, is about the book. Anything that’s about the person is a different activity and it doesn’t improve manuscripts. I also say it once. Repeating a criticism the client has heard and decided against turns honesty into pressure, and it’s their name on the cover.

The book on this: The Ghostwriting Advantage includes the case against hiring one, the conversation most people in this trade avoid.

Where does the humor come in?

In the writing, because a reader who’s amused is still reading. Nonfiction has a default tone that’s somewhere between a report and a sermon, and readers endure it instead of enjoying it. A joke does two things at once. It holds attention through material that would otherwise be dry, and it signals that a person is present.

The constraint is that the joke has to be about the subject. Humor used to decorate a paragraph is filler and readers can feel the difference. Humor that makes a point faster than the explanation would have is the good kind, and it usually replaces two sentences instead of adding one.

Nonfiction has a default tone that’s somewhere between a report and a sermon, and readers endure it instead of enjoying it.

Self-deprecation is the safest version and the most useful. My first book sold about twelve copies, and that’s the opening of Sell Your Books. That’s funny, it’s true, and it does more to establish that I know what a bad launch feels like than any amount of credentialed explanation.

What does blunt feedback cost a consultant?

Clients who wanted reassurance, and I lose them at the first meeting.

Some people are looking for somebody to execute a plan they’ve already committed to emotionally, and any assessment of that plan reads as an obstacle. Those projects are unpleasant for everybody and they usually end badly, so losing them early is a benefit disguised as a cost.

The other cost is that it doesn’t scale as marketing. A page saying I’ll tell you when your idea is weak converts fewer visitors than one promising a smooth process. It converts different ones, and the difference is the entire business.

The book on this: My Boss is Insane is nine kinds of difficult boss described without softening any of them.

Does blunt feedback work with senior people?

Better, in my experience, and consistently.

Executives spend their working lives surrounded by people who agree with them professionally. Somebody who says the accurate thing is unusual enough to be valuable, and they recognize it immediately because it’s how they got to where they are.

What senior clients dislike is being managed, hedged at, or told what somebody thinks they want to hear. They spot it faster than most people because they’ve been on the receiving end of it for decades, and the advisors who do it to them lose their trust in a single meeting.

The one adjustment is that directness with somebody senior has to come with the reasoning attached. They’ll test it, and an assertion without support fails that test in one question. I hand them the reasoning up front, because a good point that dies for lack of support helps nobody.

How blunt, honest and occasionally funny works in practice
Principle In practice
Say it in week one Twenty minutes early costs nothing; month five means heavy rewriting the client pays for.
Talk about the book, not the person Your premise doesn’t hold up, and here’s where it breaks.
Say it once Repeating a criticism the client decided against turns honesty into pressure.
Be honest about my own limits I’ve only done one traditional publisher proposal, so others may be better at it.
Make the joke about the subject A reader who’s amused is still reading, and a person is present.
Bring reasoning to senior clients They’ll test it, and an assertion without support fails in one question.
Accept the cost Clients who wanted reassurance leave at the first meeting.

My take

Bad news in week one costs less than bad news in month five. I say the uncomfortable thing early for that reason, and it costs me the clients who wanted reassurance. Those projects end badly anyway, so losing them at the first meeting suits me fine. Humor works the same way. A joke about the subject keeps a reader reading and proves a person is there. If you want someone to nod along, hire somebody else. If you want a book that works, expect the truth.

Can a ghostwriter disagree with the client?

Yes, and a ghostwriter who never does is shortchanging the client, because the alternative is a book nobody argued about.

The finished book is the client’s, in their voice, saying what they want it to say. That’s not in tension with being honest during the making of it. The honesty is how the book ends up being one they can defend instead of one that collapses the first time somebody in their industry reads it properly. My job is to make the book as good as their material allows and then get out of the way. Sometimes making it good requires telling them the chapter they love is the one to cut.

It runs both ways. I think it’s very expensive to lie, so I don’t lie, and if I do anything wrong I want the client to hit me right between the eyes and tell me. It might hurt my feelings, but it’s a hell of a lot worse to find out later. I’ve had toxic clients and toxic bosses. If a client finds something wrong, they tell me and we work it out, because the relationship comes first. That’s how I produce good books.

The rest of this series answers the questions people are usually too polite to ask: the honest case against hiring a ghostwriter, what if it doesn’t sound like me, and why don’t I just write it myself. The Ghostwriting Hub has the rest, and my ghostwriting service starts with the twenty-minute conversation nobody else wants to have.

From the author
The Ghostwriting Advantage by Richard Lowe

The Ghostwriting Advantage
Curious how a blunt ghostwriter works? The Ghostwriting Advantage is my book on how to get your book written for you, drawing on 54+ books I have ghostwritten.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should a ghostwriter tell you your book idea is weak?
Yes, and in week one. A book built on a premise that doesn’t hold needs heavy rewriting after months of interviews organized around the wrong spine. The same conversation early costs twenty minutes.
What is the difference between blunt and rude feedback?
What the sentence is about. Saying a premise doesn’t hold and showing where it breaks is about the book. Anything about the person is a different activity and doesn’t improve manuscripts.
Does humor belong in a nonfiction book?
Where it makes a point faster than the explanation would have. A joke holds attention through dry material and signals that a person is present. Humor used to decorate a paragraph is filler and readers can tell.
What does a direct working style cost a ghostwriter?
Clients who wanted reassurance instead of a collaborator, and they leave at the first meeting. Those projects usually end badly, so losing them early is a benefit that looks like a cost.
Do senior executives respond well to a blunt ghostwriter?
Consistently, in my experience. They spend their working lives around people who agree with them professionally. What they dislike is being managed or hedged at, which they detect faster than most people.

About the Author
Richard Lowe, professional ghostwriter

Richard Lowe is a professional ghostwriter and author with 113+ books authored and 54+ ghostwritten. Before writing full time he spent 33 years in enterprise technology, including 20 years as Director of Computer Operations and Technical Services at Trader Joe's. He writes nonfiction, fiction and memoir, and works with executives and experts on books that build authority.

More about Richard Lowe →

Disclaimer

The views and opinions expressed in this blog post are solely those of Richard Lowe and are based on personal experience and research. This content is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as professional legal, financial, accounting, or business advice. Always consult with qualified professionals before making important business or legal decisions. Richard Lowe is not a lawyer, accountant, or licensed professional advisor, and this content does not establish any professional relationship.

0 comments

No comments yet. Yours can be the first.

Was this useful?

Leave a comment