Latest
What You Have to Decide Before Anybody WritesWriting It Before You Need ItCross Training Covered Everything Except the Role That Mattered MostBehind the Book: You Don’t Own Anything AnymoreBehind the Book: The Woke VirusBehind the Book: Galactic InvasionWhat’s New at The Writing King: Week of November 8, 2026Alexander Zhidkov: Decision MakingJessi Szurek: Expand Your RangeYou Don’t Own Anything AnymoreThe Budget Decided How My Department Was ShapedWhy Your Competitor’s Book Is Working and Yours Would NotWhy Are These Guys Smiling? A Business Book That Became a Wrestling MemoirPangram Wants to Decide Who Gets PublishedWhat You Have Enough Material For Right NowWhen a Book Is the Wrong ToolThe Woke VirusGalactic InvasionChatGPT Turns Four: From a Free Research Preview to GPT-6What’s New at The Writing King: Week of November 1, 2026Diwali: The Festival of Lights and the Story Behind the LampsHow Much Water and Power Does Heavy AI Use Take? I Ran My Own NumbersBad Boys: Ride or Die (2024)Vesuvius Day: The Teenager Who Wrote Down Pompeii’s Last DayAnti-Communism Week: Remembering the Writers Communism SilencedVoyager 1 One Light-Day: Fifty Years to Travel One Day of LightVellum Added an Optional AI Feature. A Pile-On Killed It in a Day.Are AI Subscriptions Losing Money? The Gym Membership Math Says NoAI Terms Every Writer Should Know, and Why Each One MattersWorking While Sick: What 24/7 On Call Cost MeHe Banned AI From His Writing Group. His Own Cover Got Called AI Slop.Who Writes the Fake Fan Mail Authors Get? Inside the Scam CompoundsSMS Appointment RemindersJoe Rockey: Ghostwriting His BookDarrell Stern: Stop Being Invisible, Become UnmissableFree BooksHow to Turn Your Expertise Into a Book People Want to Read | The Expert MethodWhat’s New at The Writing King: Week of October 25, 2026Challenger Remembrance Day: The Engineer Who Wouldn’t SignJoel Salomon: The Truth About MoneyReddit Is Putting Up a Login Wall. Wikipedia Won’t Be Far Behind.Victoria Chemko: The Body Is the First TechnologySir Patrick Stewart: A TributeA Year in the Bank: ADHD, Face Blindness and the Freedom to Walk Out | The Impossible Puzzles Show, Episode 326A Yale Economist Says We Won’t Be Missed. He Forgot the Bread Line.Walter Koenig: A TributeAI Has Paid Off Outside Tech. Apollo Is Reading the Wrong Scoreboard.I Don’t Post Bad ARC Reviews. I Send the Author a Note.The Little Red Book of Stuff That Works!Your Kids Are Your Own Fault
The Writing King Your Ethical Ghostwriter. Your Story, Done Right.

Why Writing Rules Exist, and When to Break Every Single One

TL;DR: Writing rules aren’t sacred and they aren’t useless. Each one exists to prevent a failure. Once you understand the failure, you know when the rule applies and when it doesn’t. Breaking rules from mastery is style. Breaking them from ignorance is just bad writing. Learn the problem first, then decide if you have it.

Why Do Writing Rules Contradict Each Other?

Because each rule fixes a different failure, and advice written for one problem gets repeated as a law for every problem.

Writing rules make me cranky. Most of them are good advice that got promoted to law by people who never understood why it existed, and new writers pay for that by sanding every interesting thing out of their prose before anyone’s had a chance to read it.

Why writing rules contradict each otherNever use adverbs. Show do not tell. Avoid passive voice. Start with action. Kill your darlings. Write what you know. Follow all of them and writing feels like defusing a bomb. Then you pick up Cormac McCarthy, who does not use quotation marks, or José Saramago, whose paragraphs run for pages without a break, or Elmore Leonard breaking his own rules in the same book where he published them. So follow the rules or ignore them is the wrong question entirely. Every rule is a fix for a specific failure. Avoid adverbs exists because weak writers lean on said angrily instead of writing dialogue that sounds angry on its own, and the adverb patches over lazy work. If the dialogue already crackles, an occasional adverb costs nothing.Why the rules contradict each otherEvery rule is a fix for one specific failure.1The rule exists"Avoid adverbs." Stated absolutely,as though it always applies.2It was written against a failureWeak writers use "said angrily" insteadof dialogue that sounds angry3The rule patches that failureAnd nothing else. That is its whole job.4So the question changesNot "follow or ignore"but "is this the failure I have?"McCarthy drops quotation marks. Saramago runs paragraphs for pages. Leonard broke his own rulesin the book that published them.
Why writing rules contradict each otherNever use adverbs. Show do not tell. Avoid passive voice. Start with action. Kill your darlings. Write what you know. Follow all of them and writing feels like defusing a bomb. Then you pick up Cormac McCarthy, who does not use quotation marks, or José Saramago, whose paragraphs run for pages without a break, or Elmore Leonard breaking his own rules in the same book where he published them. So follow the rules or ignore them is the wrong question entirely. Every rule is a fix for a specific failure. Avoid adverbs exists because weak writers lean on said angrily instead of writing dialogue that sounds angry on its own, and the adverb patches over lazy work. If the dialogue already crackles, an occasional adverb costs nothing.Why the rules contradict eachotherEvery rule is a fix for one specific failure.1The rule exists"Avoid adverbs." Stated absolutely,as though it always applies.2It was written against a failureWeak writers use "said angrily" insteadof dialogue that sounds angry3The rule patches that failureAnd nothing else. That is its whole job.4So the question changesNot "follow or ignore"but "is this the failure I have?"McCarthy drops quotation marks. Saramago runsparagraphs for pages. Leonard broke his own rules inthe book that published them.

Never use adverbs. Show don’t tell. Avoid passive voice. Start with action. Kill your darlings. Write what you know.

Follow all of them and writing feels like defusing a bomb. One wrong move and everything explodes. Then you pick up Cormac McCarthy and he doesn’t use quotation marks. You read José Saramago and his paragraphs run for pages without a break. You read Elmore Leonard breaking his own rules in the same book where he published them. (See Elmore Leonard Day) So which is it? Follow the rules or ignore them? Neither. That’s the wrong question entirely.

Watch: These 7 Writing Rules Are Perfect ... So You Should Break Them, Bookfox

Why does every writing rule exist?

“Avoid adverbs” exists because weak writers lean on “said angrily” instead of writing dialogue that sounds angry on its own. The adverb patches over lazy work. (See also fluff words and when to keep them) If your dialogue already crackles, an occasional adverb won’t hurt anything.

“Show don’t tell” exists because amateurs stuff their manuscripts with emotional claims the reader has no reason to believe. “She was terrified” asks for trust. Showing terror through behavior earns it. But sometimes telling is faster, cleaner, and exactly what the moment needs. “Three years passed” is telling. It’s also better than showing three years of nothing important.

“Start with action” exists because new writers bury their hooks under three pages of worldbuilding nobody asked for. It doesn’t mean every novel needs to open with a car chase. It means the reader needs a reason to stay on page two.

None of these rules are arbitrary. They’re guardrails against specific screwups. Understand the screwup and you know exactly when the guardrail is protecting you and when it’s in your way.

The Passive Voice Example

Take “avoid passive voice,” the rule that gets enforced the hardest and understood the least.

The problem passive voice creates: it hides who did what. “The window was broken” conceals who broke it. “Mistakes were made” dodges responsibility. In action scenes, passive voice bleeds momentum. “He was hit by the bullet” lands softer than “The bullet tore through his shoulder.” But passive voice solves problems too.

Before and after: Let the actor drive the action scene
Before

He was hit by the bullet.

After

The bullet tore through his shoulder.

The active version puts the bullet first and keeps the momentum the post says passive voice bleeds.

When the agent doesn’t matter: “The city was founded in 1847.” Nobody cares which specific person signed the charter.

When you’re hiding information on purpose: “She was being watched.” The point is that the watcher is unknown.

When the receiver matters more than the actor: “My father was killed in the war.” The grief matters. The enemy soldier who pulled the trigger doesn’t.

Same construction. Three different effects. The rule is right sometimes and wrong sometimes, and the only way to know which is to understand what problem you’re solving in that sentence.

Should you master a writing rule before breaking it?

The “rules are meant to be broken” crowd leaves one thing out. You have to understand a rule before you can break it well. Not because breaking rules requires permission. Because it requires understanding what reader expectation you’re violating and delivering something better in its place. When McCarthy drops quotation marks, he creates an immersive, dreamlike quality where dialogue and narration blur into each other. That’s a deliberate choice serving a literary effect. When a first-time novelist drops quotation marks because they saw McCarthy do it, they create confusion and the suspicion that they don’t know basic formatting.

It’s the same decision with completely different results, and the gap between them is competence. McCarthy knows what quotation marks do, knows what readers expect when they see dialogue, and knows how to compensate for their absence.

His rule-breaking is a trade: he gives up one thing and delivers something better. Rule-breaking from ignorance gives up the same thing and delivers nothing, and I’ve got no sympathy for the writing advice that tells beginners to break rules before they’ve learned what the rules are for.

Genre Contracts Are Not Craft Rules

Some rules are promises the genre makes to its readers.

Romance readers expect a happy ending or at least a hopeful one. That’s not a suggestion. It’s the reason they picked up a romance instead of literary fiction. Violate it and you haven’t written something bold. You’ve written something that earns one-star reviews from people who feel cheated.

Mystery readers expect the clues to be available before the reveal. They want to be able to solve it, even if they didn’t. Hide the decisive clue until the last chapter and you’ve broken the contract.

I think breaking a genre contract by accident is one of the cruelest things a writer can do to their own book. The readers who feel cheated don’t come back, and they tell other readers why. Thriller readers expect escalation. Horror readers expect dread. Literary fiction readers expect ideas and emotional depth over mechanical plot.

These expectations are the reason readers choose particular genres. You can push against genre boundaries on purpose, but you need to know you’re doing it and manage the transition carefully. Accidental violations read as incompetence. Intentional ones read as innovation. The Genre Mastery Handbook maps these reader expectations across every major genre so you know exactly what contract you’re working with.

What readers expect from each genre
Genre Reader expects
Romance A happy ending, or at least a hopeful one
Mystery Clues available before the reveal, so it can be solved
Thriller Escalation
Horror Dread
Literary fiction Ideas and emotional depth over mechanical plot

How Do You Decide Whether to Break a Rule?

I think breaking a genre contract by accident is one of the cruelest things a writer can do to their own book.

Before you break a rule, run it through three questions. What problem does this rule prevent? Do I have that problem in this specific passage? And what am I giving the reader instead?

If you can answer all three, break the rule. You’ve earned it. You understand the risk, you’ve confirmed it doesn’t apply here, and you’re trading up. If you can’t answer all three, the rule is probably protecting you from something you haven’t spotted yet. Follow it. Not because rules are sacred. Because you haven’t found a better option.

McCarthy trades quotation marks for immersion. Saramago trades paragraph breaks for hypnotic, unbroken flow. Every effective rule-breaker is making a trade. If you’re not offering something better in exchange, you’re not breaking a rule. You’re making a mistake.

The rule I’d throw out first has nothing to do with prose.

I think “don’t use AI” is the most wrong piece of writing advice going around. A writer who uses AI as a digital assistant, for transcripts and summaries and first-pass outlines, and still writes the book can probably get books out four or five times faster. Writers who refuse on principle are going to find it very hard to compete with the ones who don’t.

My take

Most rule breaking I see is a mistake dressed up as style. Every writing rule exists to prevent one kind of failure. Ask what failure it guards against, whether your passage has that problem, and what the reader gets in trade. If you can’t answer all three, follow the rule. Genre contracts are the ones I’d never break by accident. The rule I’d throw out first is “don’t use AI.” Writers who refuse it on principle will have a hard time keeping up.

Which Rules Should You Never Break?

Underneath every surface-level writing rule, three things hold up the entire structure. Break any craft rule you want. These three aren’t negotiable.

Clarity. If readers can’t follow what’s happening, nothing else you do matters. You can experiment with form, voice, structure, and chronology as long as the reader stays oriented. The moment they’re lost, you’ve failed at the one job every writer has.

Causality. Events connect to each other. This happens because that happened. Random sequences of scenes are collections. Even experimental fiction maintains internal logic. Even nonlinear narratives have cause and effect.

Investment. Readers need a reason to care. Usually that’s a character they understand pursuing something that matters to them. Without investment, perfect prose is just wallpaper. Beautiful and empty.

Every other writing rule bends. Adverbs, passive voice, prologues, flashbacks, head-hopping, telling instead of showing. All of it works in the right hands for the right story. Stop asking whether something breaks a rule and ask whether it serves your reader. Answer that and the rules become what they always were: tools you pick up when you need them and set down when you don’t. The Novel Handbook covers how all of these craft decisions fit together across the full arc of a book.

Give me a writer who breaks three rules on purpose and misses on one of them over a writer who follows every rule and never takes a chance. I think the rules exist to protect readers, and too many writers hide behind them to protect themselves from the part of the work that scares them, the part where they have to decide.

From the author
Show Don't Tell by Richard Lowe

Show Don’t Tell
Show Don’t Tell takes the most repeated rule in writing and explains what it means, with more than a hundred before and after examples.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should beginners follow writing rules strictly?
Learn what each rule prevents before deciding whether to follow it. “Avoid adverbs” protects against lazy dialogue. “Show don’t tell” protects against unearned emotional claims. If you understand the failure, you can judge whether the rule applies to your specific passage. Blind obedience produces stiff writing. Blind rebellion produces bad writing, and understanding produces good decisions.
How can I tell if I’m breaking a rule effectively or just making a mistake?
Three questions: What does this rule prevent? Do I have that problem here? What am I giving the reader instead? If you can answer all three, you’re making a deliberate trade. If you can’t, the rule is probably catching something you haven’t noticed. The gap between style and error is always awareness.
Are genre conventions optional?
Not the core ones. Romance readers expect happy endings. Mystery readers expect fair clues. These promises are the reason readers chose your genre. You can push boundaries, but violating the central promise of a genre is a betrayal of the reader’s trust, and they’ll tell you so in their reviews.
What writing rules can never be broken?
Clarity, causality, and investment. Readers need to follow what’s happening, understand why events connect, and have a reason to care. Every other rule bends depending on context. These three hold up the structure that makes fiction work regardless of genre, style, or era.

About the Author
Richard Lowe, professional ghostwriter

Richard Lowe is a professional ghostwriter and author with 113+ books authored and 54+ ghostwritten. Before writing full time he spent 33 years in enterprise technology, including 20 years as Director of Computer Operations and Technical Services at Trader Joe's. He writes nonfiction, fiction and memoir, and works with executives and experts on books that build authority.

More about Richard Lowe →

Disclaimer

The views and opinions expressed in this blog post are solely those of Richard Lowe and are based on personal experience and research. This content is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as professional legal, financial, accounting, or business advice. Always consult with qualified professionals before making important business or legal decisions. Richard Lowe is not a lawyer, accountant, or licensed professional advisor, and this content does not establish any professional relationship.

One comment
Was this useful?1 of 1 found this useful

Leave a comment