More than a decade ago I wrote an essay called Friendship and Distance. It started with a woman from Romania I’d met online and turned into a list of what I think a friend is.
I reread it recently. Most of it still sounds like me. Would I sign it today? Nearly every word.
The friendship that prompted it is long over. We’re not in touch. Most of the online friendships I was celebrating back then didn’t last either. The list outlived the people who inspired it. That says something about lists, and something about people.
Every rule on that list was about the door going one way. It covered what I owe a friend, how I treat a friend, what I bring in when I walk through their door. Nothing on it said a word about what comes through my door from the other side.
Do old rules of friendship still work years later?
All of them. I’d keep every line.
The first requirement was that I care, and care deeply, about the friend and the friendship. I still do. I want my friends to succeed, I’m glad when they’re happy, and I’ll put in the effort when they’re struggling.
Never harming a friend on purpose still sits near the center. So does defending a friend when other people start the gossip. When someone starts picking a friend of mine apart behind their back, I still shut it down, and I expect the same from them. Trust and honesty are still the floor everything else stands on, and I still think a friendship with lies in it has stopped being one.
I trust my friends not to hurt me, to keep my confidences and to use good judgment with what we share. They get the same from me. When that trust breaks, no amount of shared history patches it back together, and I’ve stopped pretending otherwise.
The enabling rule has held up so well that I gave it a full article of its own, on when helping a friend becomes enabling. And the last line, that everything has to run in both directions, turned out to be the most important line on the page. I just didn’t know yet why.
| Rule | Then | Now |
|---|---|---|
| Care about the friend | The first requirement | Still the first |
| No walking on eggshells | For friends | For everybody |
| Never harm a friend | A keystone | Still a keystone |
| Don’t enable | A tricky line | Held up |
| Trust and honesty | The foundation | Still the foundation |
| It runs both ways | The last line | The most important line |
| Watch for the friend who harms you | Missing | The rule I’d add first |
No more eggshells, for anybody
Every rule on that list was about the door going one way.
Of everything on the old list, the eggshell rule has served me best. Back then I wrote that the more carefully I had to pick my words around someone, the less of a friendship we had.
I’ve stopped limiting that to friends. It covers everybody now.
I say what I want to say.
That isn’t a license to be cruel. I’m not out to hurt anyone, and I try to say things in a way that won’t cause harm.
Care in how I say something is courtesy. Fear of saying it at all is something else. A relationship where you’re afraid to speak is running on fear, and I won’t live inside one of those anymore. When I notice myself rehearsing a sentence three times before I say it to someone, that tells me more about the relationship than anything the other person has said.
People who know me know where they stand. They know I’m trustworthy and they know I’ll tell them the truth. That turns out to be worth more than any amount of tiptoeing.
Care in how you say something is courtesy. Fear of saying it at all means the relationship is running on fear.Share on X
What did my old friendship rules miss?
The friend who harms you.
My 2012 list assumed the danger in a friendship was me letting a friend down. It never considered that the friend could be the one doing the damage. I’ve learned to watch for that, and I wish I’d learned it decades sooner.
The harm doesn’t always arrive as anything dramatic. It can come through what a friend does, the words they choose, or the tone they use. The worst of it is gaslighting, because a friend who keeps telling you that what happened didn’t happen, or that you’re overreacting to something real, slowly teaches you to distrust your own judgment. I’ve written about what gaslighting does to writers, and inside a friendship it works the same way. It just has better cover, because you trust the person doing it.
Actions are the easiest to see. A friend who takes and never gives back, who only calls when they need something, leaves a trail you can follow. Words are harder, because a cutting remark can always be explained away later as a joke you were too sensitive to get. Tone is the hardest of all. Two people can say the identical sentence, and one of them means it kindly while the other means to leave a mark.
Watch all three.
The harm is subtle, and subtle is dangerous. A friend who harms you rarely looks like an enemy. They look like someone you’ve known for years, someone who means well, someone you’d feel guilty walking away from. The door stays open because it has always been open.
How do you deal with a friend who is harming you?
When you spot it, stop it. That’s the rule I’d add, and it comes in stages.
Start by talking to them. Tell them clearly what they’re doing and that it has to change. Some people don’t know they’re doing it, and one honest conversation is enough.
Pay attention to what happens after that conversation. A friend who cares about you will hear it, even if they don’t like hearing it, and the behavior will change. A friend who brushes it off, turns it around on you, or tells you that you’re imagining things has just shown you the same pattern again, in real time.
If it keeps happening, talk to them again.
And if it still doesn’t change, end the friendship. That’s the step most people can’t bring themselves to take, because the friendship has history and history feels like an obligation. It isn’t one. A friend who keeps harming you after you’ve asked them twice to stop has already decided the friendship matters less than the habit.
The ending needs no speech and no scene. You stop making the calls, stop showing up, and tell them why if they ask. The decision matters far more than the ceremony around it.
My take
My old rules were good, and they were only half the job. They told me how to treat a friend and never told me to check how a friend was treating me. Watch for harm in what a friend does, what they say and how they say it. Raise it, raise it again, and then walk if you have to. Every time I’ve walked, my life got better.
My life got better every time I let go
I’ve ended a lot of friendships since I wrote that essay. One of them had lasted decades. I held on to it for years after it stopped being good for me, because I hadn’t put a name to what was happening. When I finally figured out I was getting harmed, I let it go.
Each time I’ve done it, I’ve felt better afterward.
Each time, my life has improved. I don’t miss the friendships. I miss the years I spent in them after I should have left.
None of this breaks the old rules. It finishes them. Friendship has to run both ways, and I wrote that line at the end of the original essay. A friend who harms you has stopped holding up their side, so they’ve stopped being a friend, whatever the history says. I wrote more about toxic people and what they cost creative work, and the same pattern shows up in ordinary friendships.
If you made your own list of what a friend is, look at it again and check which way the door swings. Make sure it covers what you owe your friends and what you’re willing to accept from them. Keep the door open for the ones who treat you the way you treat them. Close it, without apology, on the ones who don’t.
I wrote it for friends whose relationships kept going wrong. It covers how to spot gaslighting, narcissism and toxic partners, and gives five ways to answer a gaslighter.
