Latest
What You Have to Decide Before Anybody WritesWriting It Before You Need ItCross Training Covered Everything Except the Role That Mattered MostBehind the Book: You Don’t Own Anything AnymoreBehind the Book: The Woke VirusBehind the Book: Galactic InvasionWhat’s New at The Writing King: Week of November 8, 2026Alexander Zhidkov: Decision MakingJessi Szurek: Expand Your RangeYou Don’t Own Anything AnymoreThe Budget Decided How My Department Was ShapedWhy Your Competitor’s Book Is Working and Yours Would NotWhy Are These Guys Smiling? A Business Book That Became a Wrestling MemoirPangram Wants to Decide Who Gets PublishedWhat You Have Enough Material For Right NowWhen a Book Is the Wrong ToolThe Woke VirusGalactic InvasionChatGPT Turns Four: From a Free Research Preview to GPT-6What’s New at The Writing King: Week of November 1, 2026Diwali: The Festival of Lights and the Story Behind the LampsHow Much Water and Power Does Heavy AI Use Take? I Ran My Own NumbersBad Boys: Ride or Die (2024)Vesuvius Day: The Teenager Who Wrote Down Pompeii’s Last DayAnti-Communism Week: Remembering the Writers Communism SilencedVoyager 1 One Light-Day: Fifty Years to Travel One Day of LightVellum Added an Optional AI Feature. A Pile-On Killed It in a Day.Are AI Subscriptions Losing Money? The Gym Membership Math Says NoAI Terms Every Writer Should Know, and Why Each One MattersWorking While Sick: What 24/7 On Call Cost MeHe Banned AI From His Writing Group. His Own Cover Got Called AI Slop.Who Writes the Fake Fan Mail Authors Get? Inside the Scam CompoundsSMS Appointment RemindersJoe Rockey: Ghostwriting His BookDarrell Stern: Stop Being Invisible, Become UnmissableFree BooksHow to Turn Your Expertise Into a Book People Want to Read | The Expert MethodWhat’s New at The Writing King: Week of October 25, 2026Challenger Remembrance Day: The Engineer Who Wouldn’t SignJoel Salomon: The Truth About MoneyReddit Is Putting Up a Login Wall. Wikipedia Won’t Be Far Behind.Victoria Chemko: The Body Is the First TechnologySir Patrick Stewart: A TributeA Year in the Bank: ADHD, Face Blindness and the Freedom to Walk Out | The Impossible Puzzles Show, Episode 326A Yale Economist Says We Won’t Be Missed. He Forgot the Bread Line.Walter Koenig: A TributeAI Has Paid Off Outside Tech. Apollo Is Reading the Wrong Scoreboard.I Don’t Post Bad ARC Reviews. I Send the Author a Note.The Little Red Book of Stuff That Works!Your Kids Are Your Own Fault
The Writing King Your Ethical Ghostwriter. Your Story, Done Right.

Most of the Books I Was Forced to Read in High School Were Crap

TL;DR: People love to say the books we were forced to read in high school were brilliant and we were too young to see it. I don’t buy it. Most of what I was assigned was crap then and it’s still crap now. A few were wonderful, Animal Farm and 1984 above all, and they had one thing in common: a story that moved. Schools pick books for what a teacher can explain, not for what a reader will finish, and that’s how they turn kids off reading for life.

There’s a comfortable myth about high school reading lists. The books were masterpieces, the story goes, and we just weren’t old enough to appreciate them. Reread them at forty and you’ll finally see the genius.

I don’t buy it. Most of the books I was forced to read in high school were crap. I was a teenager in the 1970s, and I’ve had a long time to change my mind. I haven’t.

The books were masterpieces, the story goes, and we just weren’t old enough to appreciate them.

You know the list I mean. The Scarlet Letter, The Great Gatsby, Of Mice and Men, A Separate Peace, Silas Marner, Ethan Frome. The same few dozen titles have been handed to American teenagers for generations, and most of them were picked long before any of us were born. They came with a reading schedule, a quiz on Friday, and a five-paragraph essay about symbolism at the end.

I’ve loved books my whole life, and I’ve written more than 113 of them. The ones that hooked me were almost never on a syllabus. Roger Zelazny’s Amber series, read cover to cover several times. Arthur C. Clarke’s Rendezvous with Rama.

Nobody assigned me those. I found them, and they kept me reading.

The masterpiece argument bothers me for that reason. It does real harm. It lets the people who choose these lists off the hook, and it tells every adult who secretly hated those books that the problem was them. Millions of kids walked out of English class convinced that reading is a chore. I’d say the books had a lot to do with that.

A post went around a book group this week making the masterpiece argument, and hundreds of people agreed with it. Plenty didn’t. One reader said she was an avid reader in high school and the assigned books were “the worst of the worst.” Another reread The Catcher in the Rye as an adult and called it a terrible book for high school or anyone. Those are my people.

Were the books we read in high school any good?

Some were. Most weren’t. My scorecard is short. Animal Farm and 1984 were fantastic. I loved both, and I still do. Half the country treats Moby-Dick as a punishment. I liked it. Huckleberry Finn I liked.

The Scarlet Letter I couldn’t get into. The Great Gatsby I didn’t like. Of Mice and Men I didn’t like. The Grapes of Wrath I didn’t like. A Christmas Carol I read even earlier, in grade school, and found mediocre. The movies are better, depending on the movie, because a good cast and a good director can lift a story that sits flat on the page.

The rest of that list, the Silas Marners and Ethan Fromes and A Separate Peaces of the world, I can sum up in one line. I read them, I didn’t like them, and I’ve never felt the urge to go back.

That’s a lot of years of required reading, and a handful of winners. If a restaurant served you that ratio, would you keep going back? I wouldn’t.

My scorecard for the books I was assigned.
Book Verdict Note
Animal Farm Fantastic Big ideas in a story that moves
1984 Fantastic Loved it then, still do
Moby-Dick Liked it Some whale chapters are a slog, but you want to see how it ends
Huckleberry Finn Liked it Huck is on a raft going somewhere
The Scarlet Letter Couldn’t get into it Great for teaching symbols, not for reading
The Great Gatsby Didn’t like it On the same list for generations
Of Mice and Men, The Grapes of Wrath Didn’t like them Reread as an adult and still didn’t
A Christmas Carol Mediocre Read in grade school; the movies are better
Silas Marner, Ethan Frome, A Separate Peace Didn’t like them Never felt the urge to go back

Most of the books I was forced to read in high school were crap, and getting older didn’t change my mind. – Richard Lowe
Share on X

Watch: I reread my favorite book from middle school and it was bad., Katy Fae

What do the books students like have in common?

Look at my winners again. Animal Farm. 1984. Moby-Dick. Huckleberry Finn.

Every one of them is a story first. Orwell wrapped big ideas in a farm full of talking animals and a man trying to stay human in a nightmare, and you turn the page because you need to know what happens to Boxer and Winston. Melville goes off on whales for chapters at a time, and I’ll admit some of those chapters are a slog, but there’s a madman chasing a monster across the ocean and you want to see how it ends. Huck is on a raft going somewhere.

Now look at the losers. Most of them are mood pieces, character studies and slow tragedies. In most of them the meaning hides in symbols, and the reader digs it out for a test. They might be fine books for an adult who chose them. For a fifteen-year-old who didn’t, they’re a wall. I’ve written about why some books connect and others don’t, and it applies here too. Readers come back to stories that pull them forward. Prestige doesn’t keep anybody turning pages.

Why do schools pick books students hate?

Because the books get chosen for teaching, and students come second.

A teacher needs a book with themes to discuss, symbols to find, and an essay question at the end of every chapter. The Scarlet Letter is wonderful for that. There’s a giant red symbol right in the title. Whether a teenager will want to read it is somebody else’s problem.

Then there’s inertia. Who decided a fifteen-year-old needed Ethan Frome? Somebody, decades ago, and nobody has questioned it since. A book lands on the list, the teacher builds lesson plans around it, the department buys a hundred copies, and it stays for forty years because changing it is work. Nobody asks whether it still reaches anyone.

Add the book report, and you’ve finished the job. One woman in that thread remembered Silas Marner by title alone, and nothing else, except that she was forced to read something boring and confusing and then write what she thought her teacher wanted to hear. The system teaches it every year. Reading becomes a chore you fake your way through.

Teachers matter, and the thread was full of people saying so. A retired English teacher described teaching Elizabethan dancing while her class read Shakespeare, and having students write by candlelight with quills while they read the Brontës. That’s a teacher who understood that a book needs a doorway. Most of us didn’t get that teacher. We got a reading schedule and a quiz on Friday.

Is it true we were too young to appreciate the classics?

Sometimes. Mostly, it’s an excuse. I don’t doubt that some people reread Of Mice and Men at fifty and see things they missed at fifteen. Life adds context. One man in the thread reread Steinbeck with students and said the book showed him the Depression better than his history training ever did. (More on John Steinbeck Day) Good for him. That’s a real experience.

But the argument has a hidden assumption, and I hate it. It says the book is always right and the reader is always wrong. If you didn’t like it, you weren’t old enough, smart enough or patient enough. The book never gets blamed. Why is it always the reader’s fault?

I think it’s a terrible way to approach reading. Books are made by people, and people make mistakes. Some books are overrated. Some were great for their time and haven’t aged well. Some were only ever popular with the people who choose what goes on reading lists. Telling a reader they were wrong to be bored is how you turn a kid who loves stories into an adult who never opens a book again.

And plenty of us did grow up, did reread, and still didn’t like them. I’m old enough now. I still don’t.

Why the old classics read better as stories than as poems

Some of the oldest stories in the world grabbed me hard, as long as nobody made me read them as poetry.

I read the first part of Dante’s Inferno in an edition that turned it into narrative prose, and I loved it. I hated the poems. Same with the Iliad and the Odyssey. I was deep into the Greek material, the gods and the wars and the long road home, but only as story. Put it back in verse and I was gone.

I’ve got nothing against poetry. My point is about doors. The story of a man walking down through the circles of hell is as good an idea as anyone has ever had. If the only way in is a translation of medieval Italian verse, most readers will never get to see it. A prose version opened that door for me, and Dante has stayed with me ever since.

Schools could learn something there. Teach the story first. Let students fall for Odysseus before you ask them to scan the meter.

Is it worth reading a hard book that turned out to be wrong?

Yes, and I have a strange example. I read Edward Gibbon’s The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. I read all six volumes. It was a tough read, and it was interesting. I’ve also come to accept that a lot of it is out of date. Historians have spent two centuries correcting Gibbon, and he came to the wrong conclusions in a lot of ways. I’d still tell anyone with the patience to read it.

I also got about halfway through a volume of Josephus. It was a good translation, and it was a bit much for me. Gibbon was harder than anything on my high school list, and I finished it. So difficulty was never the problem. The problem is being forced to read something that gives you nothing back. Hard and rewarding is worth it. Hard and dull is homework.

What should high schools assign instead?

I’m not a teacher, so take this as a reader’s opinion. This would have worked on me.

Start with stories that move. Orwell proves a book can carry big ideas and still be a page-turner. Give students the books that make readers, and save the slow literary novels for later, when they’ve got the habit and can choose them for themselves. Let students pick some of their own books. The kids who read Michener and Uris on their own time, like one reader in the thread, weren’t getting less out of it. They were getting more, because they wanted to be there.

Use the movies. A good adaptation is a doorway, the way the films did more for A Christmas Carol than Dickens’s own text did for me. I wrote about that on Charles Dickens Day.

And stop treating dislike as failure. A student who says a book is boring is giving you data. Listen to it.

My take

Schools keep handing teenagers books built for a lecture, and then they wonder why those kids stop reading. Difficulty was never my problem. I finished all six volumes of Gibbon. They were harder than anything on my high school list. Dull was the problem. Give students stories that move, like Animal Farm and 1984, and let them pick some books for themselves. A kid who calls a book boring is giving you data. Listen to it.

Why it matters for every writer

Writers should care about this more than anyone, because school reading lists shape who becomes a reader. Every kid who decides books are boring at fifteen is a reader you’ll never reach at forty. It also teaches a lesson about our own books. Nobody is forced to read what we write. They have to want to. The books that survived my high school list would’ve survived without it, because they hold a reader by the collar. That’s the job, whether you’re Orwell or a first-time novelist.

If you want help building a book people choose to read, more on craft is in the Writing Hub, and my book coaching is built for writers who want readers to finish what they start.

Animal Farm never needed a teacher to defend it. That’s the test every book on that list should have to pass.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do so many people hate the books they read in high school?
Many assigned books are chosen because they’re easy to teach, with themes and symbols for essays, not because teenagers will enjoy them. Add a reading schedule, quizzes and a book report, and reading becomes a chore students fake their way through.
Should adults reread the books they hated in high school?
If you’re curious, try one. Some books open up with life experience, and some readers find more in them at forty. If it still bores you, put it down. If you still dislike a classic as an adult, blame the book.
Which high school books do students tend to like?
Books with a story that moves, like Animal Farm, 1984 and Huckleberry Finn, hold students far better than slow character studies. Big ideas land best when they’re wrapped in a plot that pulls the reader forward.
Is it better to read the Iliad and Dante in prose or verse?
For many readers, prose translations are the way in. A prose Inferno or Odyssey lets a reader fall for the story first, and the poetry can come later for those who want it.
Should high school students choose their own books?
Letting students pick some of their own books builds the reading habit. Readers who choose books want to be there. That habit turns them into adults who keep reading.
Is Gibbon’s Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire still worth reading?
Yes, for readers with patience. It’s long and hard, and historians have corrected many of Gibbon’s conclusions over two centuries, but it’s still a great read on Rome and on how history gets written.
What can writers learn from high school reading lists?
Nobody is forced to read a new author’s book. The books that survive required reading are the ones readers would have finished anyway, because the story pulls them forward. That’s the standard every writer has to meet.

About the Author
Richard Lowe, professional ghostwriter

Richard Lowe is a professional ghostwriter and author with 113+ books authored and 54+ ghostwritten. Before writing full time he spent 33 years in enterprise technology, including 20 years as Director of Computer Operations and Technical Services at Trader Joe's. He writes nonfiction, fiction and memoir, and works with executives and experts on books that build authority.

More about Richard Lowe →

Disclaimer

The views and opinions expressed in this blog post are solely those of Richard Lowe and are based on personal experience and research. This content is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as professional legal, financial, accounting, or business advice. Always consult with qualified professionals before making important business or legal decisions. Richard Lowe is not a lawyer, accountant, or licensed professional advisor, and this content does not establish any professional relationship.

0 comments

No comments yet. Yours can be the first.

Was this useful?

Leave a comment