Everybody has been in the same book club. Twelve people signed up. Four read the book. Two skimmed it. One read a summary on the drive over. The conversation covers the plot for nine minutes and then turns into a conversation about something else entirely. That’s usually the best part of the evening and isn’t what anybody came for.
The silent version removes the assigned book, and with it the guilt, the homework and the performance.
I think the silent book club is the best idea the reading world has had in years, and I’m a little annoyed nobody came up with it sooner. The conventional club punishes busy people and shy people, and this format simply stops doing that.
What happens at a silent book club?
People arrive with whatever they’re already reading. Somebody says hello. Then everybody reads, in the same room, for an hour or so. Afterwards there’s usually a bit of talk, and it’s optional, and it tends to be about what you’re reading now instead of what you were told to read. That’s the whole format. Nobody works through discussion questions, no reading schedule, no title chosen by committee.
A silent book club has four parts, and only the reading in the middle is required.
Nobody has to have finished anything. Nobody has to have opinions ready. You can turn up with a thriller, a biography, a book about bees, or the same novel you’ve been failing to finish since March.
| Conventional book club | Silent book club | |
|---|---|---|
| The book | One title chosen by committee | Whatever you are already reading |
| Preparation | Buy it, finish it by the deadline, have opinions ready | Turn up holding a book |
| The meeting | Structured discussion of the assigned book | About an hour of reading in the same room |
| Conversation | Required, and often drifts off the book | Short, optional, afterwards, about what people chose |
| Order of things | Be sociable first, read second | Read first; company is optional and afterwards |
| Who it filters out | New arrivals, anxious people and busy people | Almost nobody; the floor is low |
Why it works
Three reasons, and the first is about attention.
Reading at home competes with everything else in the house. Reading in a room where eleven other people are also reading is a completely different experience, because the social pressure that normally works against you is suddenly working for you. Nobody gets their phone out. You read for an hour without deciding to.
The second is about the barrier. A conventional book club asks for a commitment before you’ve met anybody: buy this, finish it by the fourteenth, have something to say. A silent book club asks you to turn up holding a book. For anybody new to an area, or anxious, or simply busy, that difference decides whether they come at all.
The third is what happens afterwards. The conversation people have when there’s no assigned text is about what they liked. That’s far more useful for finding your next read than a structured discussion of one novel everybody was obliged to buy.
That third point is the one that convinces me. A stranger raving about a book they picked freely beats any discussion guide printed in the back of a novel, and those guides have always struck me as homework in a party hat.
Where the format came from
The idea is simple enough that several people arrived at it independently, and it spread the way good simple ideas do, through people copying it without asking anybody’s permission.
The structure that stuck is roughly an hour of silent reading in a shared room, bookended by a short unstructured social period. No membership, no fee beyond whatever the venue sells, and no obligation to return.
What made it spread is that it works in rooms that already exist. A bookshop with seating, a brewery on a quiet night, a cafe after the lunch rush, a library meeting room. The format has no equipment and no overhead. That means anybody willing to name a time and a place can run one.
It also solved a problem nobody had named out loud.
Reading is solitary and most people like it that way, and a great many of those same people are lonely and would rather not be. A conventional book club asks them to be sociable first and read second. The silent version reverses it: you get the reading, and the company is optional and afterwards.
That reversal is the whole innovation and it turns out to matter enormously.
I admire that reversal a great deal. Organizers built most social formats for readers on the assumption that everybody wants to talk first, and the quiet readers paid for that assumption by staying home.
What an hour of protected reading is worth
Most people who say they’ve stopped reading haven’t lost the ability or the appetite. They’ve lost the hour.
Reading is solitary and most people like it that way, and a great many of those same people are lonely and would rather not be.
Reading at home competes with every other thing in the house, and it competes badly, because a book asks for sustained attention and everything else is designed to interrupt it. A phone within reach wins that fight most evenings. An hour in a room where eleven other people are also reading is a completely different proposition. The social pressure that normally works against sustained attention is suddenly working for it. Nobody reaches for a phone. You read for an hour without having to decide to, repeatedly, against resistance.
The people who get the most out of this are the ones with a book they’ve been failing to finish since March, which is most people, and who need one reliable hour instead of more willpower.
If you’re a writer, the case is stronger again. Writers who have stopped reading widely are easy to spot on the page, because the range of sentences available to them narrows and they start producing the only kind of paragraph they still read. That’s usually their own.
This is the stake that worries me for writers. When a writer stops reading, the prose goes thin and starts repeating itself, and the writer is usually the last to notice. An hour a month in a quiet room is a cheap fix for a problem that can sink a career.
Where are silent book clubs in Tampa Bay?
The Gilded Page in Tarpon Springs runs silent book clubs as part of a program that also includes conventional book clubs, trivia, open mic and storytime. The shop has a reading lounge at the back with couches and an oversized chess set, and the owner hand-orders every book in the building, so the room is suited to it.
Pages and Perks in St. Petersburg has themed silent reading evenings on its announced program, alongside yoga, game nights and Dungeons and Dragons.
Beyond those two, the format moves around. Bookshops, cafes, breweries and libraries all host them at various points, and they’re organized through social media instead of a permanent listing. The practical advice is to check the social channels of the shops in the bookstore series instead of searching for a fixed calendar, because there’s not one. Libraries are the other place to look. Dunedin runs an adult summer reading program with extra events attached, and most branches in the county program for adults year-round with registration.
I’m very pleased to see Tampa Bay shops making room for this. A bookshop that gives an evening to quiet reading is betting on readers, and I want that bet to pay off for both of them.
How do you start a silent book club?
This is easier than people assume, and the requirements are almost nothing. You need a room where sitting quietly for an hour is normal, somebody willing to say a start time out loud, and a few people. That’s it. No budget, no speaker, no reading list.
Public libraries in this county have free bookable rooms and they’re under-used. Seminole has free private rooms on a first-come basis, Clearwater Countryside takes reservations, and the Obama Main Library books meeting rooms big enough for a training session. The Gilded Page rents its back lounge.
A bookshop with seating will often say yes for nothing, because a dozen readers in the building for an hour is good for them. Ask.
Running one properly
Since the requirements are nearly nothing, these are the things that separate the ones that last from the ones that meet twice.
Name a fixed time and keep it. The first Tuesday of the month at seven, every month, regardless of how many people turned up last time. Groups die from irregularity far more often than from low attendance, because a floating date requires everybody to check, and checking is friction. Start on time and say so out loud. A clear start is what converts a room of people holding books into an hour of reading. Somebody has to say the sentence.
Keep the social part short and optional. Ten or fifteen minutes at the end, and make it obvious that leaving at the hour is normal. The moment attendance implies a social obligation, the people who came for the format stop coming. Don’t assign anything, whether a theme, a genre or a suggested title. The absence of homework is the product. Resist growing it. A dozen people in a room reading is the format working. Forty people is an event, and events need organizing, and organizing is what kills volunteer-run things.
That last rule is the one organizers break, and I understand the temptation, since growth feels like success. It kills more good volunteer groups than apathy ever does, and I’d defend a twelve-person room against anybody with an expansion plan.
And pick a venue that wants you there. A bookshop with seating generally does, because a dozen readers in the building for an hour is good for them. Ask directly and offer a specific time. Most independent shops in this county are considerably more approachable than people assume. That’s a theme running through the whole bookstore series.
What a writer gets out of it
Two things that have nothing to do with socializing.
The first is the hour. A silent book club is an hour of protected reading time with external accountability. That’s the thing most writers claim they can’t find and then fill with something else.
The second is the data. Sit in a room of readers and listen to the optional ten minutes at the end. You’ll hear what people finish, what they abandoned, what they bought because of a cover, and how they describe a book they loved to somebody who hasn’t read it. That last one is your back cover copy, spoken aloud by the person you’re writing for.
If you want structured feedback on your own work instead, that’s a different room, and I’ve written about finding a writing group worth sitting in.
Why it suits people who dread book clubs
A conventional book club asks for three commitments before you’ve met anybody. Buy this. Finish it by the fourteenth. Have something to say about it. For anybody new to an area, anxious about groups, or simply busy, that’s enough friction to prevent attendance entirely. And the people it filters out are the ones who would benefit most from being in a room with other readers.
The silent version asks you to turn up holding a book. There’s nothing to prepare, nothing to have read, and nothing to say. If the conversation at the end is more than you want, you leave at the hour and nobody notices. That low floor is why these groups draw people who have never been to a book club in their lives, and why they hold on to them.
That’s why I’m rooting for this format. Plenty of people who’d thrive in a room full of readers never got one because the price of entry was pretending to have finished a novel, and a group that drops that price is doing real good.
What to bring, and what to expect
Whatever you’re reading. That’s the entire requirement, because the commonest reason people don’t attend a first one is a suspicion that there’s an unstated standard.
There’s not. A literary novel, a thriller, a biography, a book about bees, a manga volume, a print-out of something, an e-reader. Nobody will look, and if anybody does look it’s because they’re wondering whether to read it themselves.
Arrive a few minutes early, because walking into a room that’s already gone quiet is the one awkward moment in the format. Bring something to drink if the venue sells one, both because it’s polite to the host and because an hour is longer than you think.
Expect the first twenty minutes to be harder than you remember. Sustained reading is a muscle and most people haven’t used it properly in a while. It settles.
And expect the conversation at the end to be better than a book club discussion. Nobody is performing familiarity with an assigned text, so what gets said is what people thought about something they chose. That’s a rarer conversation than it sounds.
If there is nothing near you
These appear and disappear. They’re volunteer-run, publicized through social media, and dependent on one person continuing to care. So the practical advice is to check the social channels of the shops in this series instead of hunting for a central calendar, because there’s not one. The Gilded Page and Pages and Perks are the two with silent reading on their announced programs, and others surface intermittently at bookshops, cafes, breweries and libraries across the county.
Libraries are the under-checked option. Most branches in this county run adult programming year-round with registration, and Dunedin runs an adult summer reading program with events attached. That’s closer in spirit to this than anything else on a library calendar.
And if nothing exists within a reasonable drive, start one. A room, a time, and three people is a silent book club. It doesn’t need to be more than that, and every one that exists now started exactly there.
My take
Silent book clubs are the best thing to happen to reading groups in years. They drop the one requirement that kept people away, pretending you’d finished the assigned novel. Bring whatever you’re reading and show up a few minutes early. The Gilded Page and Pages and Perks both run one. If nobody near you does, start it yourself. A room, an hour and three people is enough.
A format that admits the truth
The quiet achievement of the silent book club is that it stopped pretending.
Book clubs were always partly about the room and the company and getting out of the house, and only partly about the book. The silent version drops the pretense, keeps the room and the company, and hands the choice of book back to the person doing the reading.
What’s left is an hour of reading among people who also wanted an hour of reading, and a short conversation afterwards with no wrong answers in it. I’d pick that over a traditional book club any night of the week, and if nobody near you runs one, you should be the person who says the start time out loud.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Witty banter optional: The no-pressure, no-homework book club, The Christian Science Monitor
- A family-friendly bookstore and mocktail bar is opening by Roser Park in St. Pete, I Love the Burg
