7 / 10
Official trailer
The Outsiders is Francis Ford Coppola’s 1983 adaptation of S.E. Hinton’s 1967 novel. Greasers Ponyboy Curtis and Johnny Cade live in 1965 Tulsa, Oklahoma, caught in a class war with the middle-class Socs. After Johnny kills a Soc to defend Ponyboy, the boys hide in an abandoned country church until Johnny is fatally hurt saving children from a fire there, and Dallas Winston dies soon after. C. Thomas Howell, Ralph Macchio, Matt Dillon, Patrick Swayze, Rob Lowe, Emilio Estevez, Tom Cruise and Diane Lane lead the cast.
I enjoy The Outsiders more than I probably should. It’s earnest, overheated and sometimes clumsy, and I still get caught up in it, mostly because Macchio and Dillon make those boys feel like people. What holds it at a 7 is that Coppola never quite settles on how big this story ought to feel.
Coppola’s The Outsiders is the principal screen adaptation of S.E. Hinton’s novel and this film that launched multiple young performers whose later careers extended across multiple decades.
Coppola directed the film between his more major productions of the period including The Cotton Club (1984). The Outsiders represents middle-tier Coppola instead of peak Coppola. The casting brings together what later decades would recognize as the Brat Pack generation of American film actors.
Tom Cruise, Rob Lowe, Emilio Estevez, Patrick Swayze, Matt Dillon, and Ralph Macchio all received early career exposure through the production. The combined talent gives the film weight that its individual artistic achievements may not fully justify. Spotting future stars in small parts is half the fun for me, and I don’t think that’s a bad reason to watch.
The Ensemble Casting
The casting director assembled an unusual collection of young male performers who would become major American stars across the later decade. Tom Cruise had completed Taps (1981) but hadn’t yet made Risky Business (1983) or Top Gun (1986). Patrick Swayze was thirty during production and would later star in Dirty Dancing (1987) and Ghost (1990). Rob Lowe was eighteen and would join the Brat Pack through later films including St. Elmo’s Fire (1985). Matt Dillon had already appeared in multiple earlier productions.
The assembled cast represents one of the more unusual single-production gatherings of later major performers in American cinema.
The pattern of single films assembling future stars has continued.
Diner (1982) brought together Mickey Rourke, Kevin Bacon, Steve Guttenberg, Daniel Stern, and others. The Outsiders did the same. Critics have argued that such productions function as casting visibility events for the assembled performers instead of as artistically unified works. The Outsiders supports this reading. The individual performances don’t consistently match the talent the performers would later show. The casting exceeded what the work required.
For Writers
Productions sometimes function as visibility events for participants instead of as artistically unified works. The same applies to creative work. What a project accomplishes outweighs what it nominally pursues.
The S.E. Hinton Source
S.E. Hinton wrote the novel at age seventeen, drawing on her observations of social-class conflict at her Tulsa high school.
The novel was published in 1967 when Hinton was nineteen. The book has remained continuously in print and continues to receive considerable educational adoption in American middle and high school curricula. Few young adult novels have achieved comparable sustained presence in school reading lists.
The novel’s depicted social-class conflict captures specific 1960s American concerns about juvenile delinquency, urban poverty, and intergenerational alienation.
The greasers and Socs distinction reflected actual subculture divisions in midwestern American cities. Hinton’s depicted violence, deaths, and emotional content gave young adult fiction permission to engage adult themes that previous YA literature had typically avoided. Later young adult novels have continued to draw on the template Hinton established. The Outsiders represents foundational work in the modern YA tradition.
I think Hinton’s book is the reason the film still works at all. The feeling of being a teenager and certain the whole world is against you comes straight off her pages, and the film is at its best when it trusts that feeling.
For Writers
Young writers can produce work that addresses adult themes successfully. Novelists should keep this one in mind. The age of the author doesn’t determine what themes the work can engage.
The Coppola Direction
Francis Ford Coppola directed The Outsiders as smaller-scale work between his more major productions of the period. The film works at conventional teen drama scale instead of at the epic scale that The Godfather (1972), The Godfather Part II (1974), and Apocalypse Now (1979) had built for Coppola’s reputation. The smaller scale produces uneven results. The film achieves emotional moments but doesn’t consistently sustain the dramatic weight that the content asks for.
The unevenness loses me in places. One scene is shot like grand tragedy and the next like an after-school special, and I can feel Coppola straining to make the material bigger than it wants to be. The church fire and Dally’s death hit hard, and the stretches between them sag.
Coppola later released a director’s cut titled The Outsiders: The Complete Novel (2005) that adds approximately twenty minutes of material removed from the theatrical release.
The longer version provides additional character development and somewhat reduces the unevenness that the original release exhibits. Whether the longer version represents the intended work or constitutes overcorrection has been debated. The original release remains the film most audiences have encountered. The director’s cut justifies engagement for audiences who want fuller treatment of the content.
I prefer the longer cut. The extra twenty minutes give the brothers room to breathe, and the film feels less like a string of big moments.
For Writers
Smaller-scale work from directors known for epic productions can produce uneven results. The same logic applies to creative work. The conditions right for one scale of production may not apply to a different scale.
Craft Note
Francis Ford Coppola directed The Outsiders during a period when his commercial standing had declined from his 1970s peak. The financial difficulties of his independent productions including One from the Heart (1982) constrained his later choices. The Outsiders represents commercial assignment that maintained his career through a difficult professional period. Directors of real talent can produce uneven work during career transitions when financial pressure shapes their material selection.
Does The Outsiders still hold up?
For S.E. Hinton’s novel, The Outsiders is the principal screen adaptation, and it launched a whole generation of young stars. I give it a 7 because the big moments hit hard and the stretches between them never find a steady tone. The cast is better than the film, and the director’s cut fixes some of that. Watch it if you care about teen cinema, the Brat Pack or Hinton’s book, and pick the longer version if you can.
