If every question in your dialogue gets a clean, direct answer in the order it was asked, you’ve written a police report.
Real people don’t talk like that. The person who taught me this wasn’t a writing instructor. She was a bellydancer named Marjhani, and she never read a word I wrote.
The Bellydance Photographer
The thermometer had crept past a hundred degrees by midday at the Renaissance Faire. I’d claimed a spot in the back row of the bellydance stage, on straw bales arranged in half-circles facing the performance area. A massive oak overhung where I sat, and I leaned into its shade with something close to gratitude.
I chose the back row for practical reasons.
I could shoot over the heads of everyone in front of me. But that wasn’t the only reason. I was still caved in from grief, still moving through the world trying not to be noticed. The back row let me observe without participating. I could hide behind my camera and pretend I was just a spectator passing through.
When the show ended, I sat for a moment longer, letting the heat wash back over me. That was when I noticed a short, dark-skinned woman walking directly toward me. Marjhani scared the crap out of me.
She was forceful and didn’t hesitate to loudly make her opinion known. She occupied space unapologetically. She was everything I wasn’t. She walked right up and introduced herself. Told me she and her dancers enjoyed the pictures I took. I’d been uploading photos to a website, letting people use them without charge. The dancers had found them.
Then she said something that changed everything.
I was now officially part of the troupe. Their photographer. Before I could protest or retreat to the safety of my back-row anonymity, she put her arms around me and gave me a big hug.
For months I had been drifting through life like a ghost. Physical contact had become rare. Warmth had become rare. And here was this stranger, this force of nature, pulling me into an embrace like I was family.
She dragged me to the front of the stage and introduced me to the other dancers. Every single one gave me a hug. The women. The men. All of them welcomed me like I belonged there. One more thing. I was no longer allowed to sit in the back row. From now on, she expected to see me front row center. She’d reserve my spot by writing my name on a piece of paper and pinning it to a straw bale. That paper flag marked my place in a community I hadn’t known I needed.
The full story of that day: The Day Everything Changed
Four hundred thousand photos over eight years. Renaissance faires, studio sessions, performances at restaurants and festivals and private parties. I shot so many images that photography stopped being a hobby and started being a discipline. And that discipline taught me more about writing than any craft book I’d read.
What a Camera Can’t Do
A camera can’t record thoughts.
I couldn’t photograph “she felt nervous before going onstage.” I could only catch the way her fingers twisted the fabric of her hip scarf. The quick glance toward the exit. The breath she held just before the music started.
Nine hundred eighty thousand images later, I’d trained myself to see external signals of internal states. The tells. The body language. The moment before the mask goes on. Photography forces pure showing. No narration. No internal monologue. Just what the eye can capture.
That transfers directly to prose.
Writers get lazy with interiority. “She felt sad.” “He was angry.” “They were nervous.” The camera taught me to delete those sentences and ask: what does sad look like from the outside? What does angry do with its hands? Where does nervous put its eyes?
I’m hard on this in every draft I write, mine and my clients’. “She felt sad” tells me the writer didn’t look closely enough at the person to know what sad did to her, and a reader can feel that gap even when they can’t name it. It’s the most common weakness in amateur fiction and memoir, and it’s the easiest one to fix once you start watching hands.
A dancer preparing to perform doesn’t think “I’m anxious.” She checks her costume three times. Adjusts a hairpin that doesn’t need adjusting. Laughs a little too loud at someone’s joke.
I learned to watch hands instead of faces. Faces lie. Hands tell the truth. The way someone grips a coffee cup. The finger tapping against a thigh. The sudden stillness when a name gets mentioned. Eight years of shooting performers taught me that the story is in the moments between poses.
The AI-Enhanced Showing and Telling Handbook breaks this down systematically. When to stay external, when interiority belongs, how to balance the two.
Why does my dialogue sound like a police report?
Most dialogue in amateur manuscripts looks like this:
“Did you take the money?”
“Yes, I took the money. I needed it for my mother’s surgery. She’s been sick for three months and the insurance won’t cover the procedure.”
Clean. Complete. Responsive. Every question answered directly, every sentence finished, all relevant information delivered efficiently. Also completely fake. Real people don’t talk like that. They interrupt. They deflect. They answer questions nobody asked while dodging the ones on the table. They trail off mid-sentence when something hurts too much to finish. The police-report version comes from writers who don’t trust their readers. They’re afraid somebody will miss the point, so they hand over a full confession in one clean breath. I’d much prefer a reader miss a detail than sit through dialogue no living person would ever speak, because that second kind tells the reader the writer thinks they’re slow.
“Did you take the money?”
“My mother, she’s…” A hand moves to the throat. “The insurance, you know how they are. Three months watching her just… and they send these letters, these damn letters that say…”
“The money. Did you take it?”
“What would you have done?”
The second version tells you everything the first one does, but through behavior instead of exposition. The hand at the throat. The unfinished sentences. The deflection into a counter-question.
I ghostwrite memoirs now, and I see the same principle in interviews. Last week a client told me about her father’s death. She didn’t say “I was devastated.” She said “I kept his coffee mug in the cabinet for three years. Couldn’t throw it out. Every morning I’d see it and think, I should deal with that. And then I’d close the cabinet.”
That’s showing. That’s what people do with grief. The mug says more than “I was devastated” ever could.
Memoir clients cry in my interviews all the time, and some of them get embarrassed about it. I tell them the emotion belongs in the book. Then my job is to get it onto the page the way that mug got there, through what they did, because a line like “she was devastated” would throw away the very thing they trusted me with.
The camera taught me to see those moments. The performer who won’t look directly at her partner during a duet. The quick adjustment of a smile that slipped. The shoulder that tightens when a certain song starts. The cabinet that stays closed. Writing dialogue means capturing what people do while they’re talking, instead of only what they say.
The AI-Enhanced Dialogue Handbook covers subtext, speech patterns, interruptions, and the things characters won’t say. 276 pages on creating voices readers can distinguish without tags.
The Discipline That Transfers
I still shoot sometimes. Not as much as I used to. But the training stays.
When I write, I see the scene through a viewfinder. What would the camera catch? What would stay invisible? If I can’t photograph it, I probably shouldn’t be telling readers about it directly.
The core insight came from a dusty ren faire and a woman named Marjhani who decided I belonged in the front row whether I liked it or not.
Your dialogue sounds like a police report because you’re transcribing instead of capturing.
Fix that before you show the manuscript to anybody. Readers will forgive a clumsy sentence long before they forgive characters who sound like they’re reading a statement into the record, and I’ll put a book down for that faster than for almost any other flaw.
Frequently Asked Questions
Ready to Master Dialogue?
Get the AI-Enhanced Dialogue Handbook or explore the full AI Writer’s Library.
