An Unquiet Mind: A Memoir of Moods and Madness

An Unquiet Mind by Kay Redfield Jamison is a landmark memoir of mental illness, distinguished by a perspective almost no other book can offer: its author is both a sufferer of bipolar disorder and one of the world’s foremost clinical authorities on it.

Jamison is a professor of psychiatry who has spent her career studying and treating manic-depressive illness.

She writes from inside the experience she’s also devoted her professional life to understanding, recounting her own struggle with the disease, the seductive highs of mania, the devastating depressions, a suicide attempt, and the long, resisted reconciliation with the medication that keeps her alive. That dual authority makes the book uniquely valuable and credible, and it puts the glib pop-psychology books that talk about mental illness from a safe distance to shame. It gets a high rating from me as a candid, beautifully written, definitive account.

The singular value is that double vantage point. Jamison can describe what mania and depression feel like from the inside. She can also explain, with a clinician’s precision, what’s happening, a combination that almost no other account of mental illness offers.

The expert as patient

The book’s defining strength is its rare dual perspective. Jamison is a leading researcher on the illness she suffers from. That lets her render the subjective experience of bipolar disorder, the intoxicating, dangerous euphoria and grandiosity of mania and the crushing, suicidal weight of depression, with a vividness born of lived experience, while at the same time framing it with clinical understanding and scientific context.

The reader gets the felt reality of the illness and an authoritative explanation of it. That combination demystifies manic-depressive illness without reducing it to a case study, and I trust her for it, because the clinician in her never tidies up what the patient went through. For anyone seeking to understand bipolar disorder, from the inside and the outside at once, the book is uniquely illuminating, and that’s why it became a touchstone in the literature of mental illness.

Watch: An Unquiet Mind: Kay Jamison, Vanderbilt University

Candor, craft, and the medication question

Beyond its expertise, the memoir succeeds through its honesty and its prose. Jamison writes beautifully, with a clarity and lyricism unusual in clinical territory, and she’s unsparingly candid about her own behavior, the reckless spending, the damaged relationships, the shame, the years she dangerously refused the lithium that controls her illness because she missed the highs of mania.

That last thread, her long, resisted acceptance of medication, is one of the book’s most valuable, illuminating why people with bipolar disorder so often stop treatment, a difficult truth she renders with rare empathy and self-awareness. Her admission that she missed the highs is the bravest thing in the book, and it explains more about why people quit their medication than a stack of clinical papers. The combination of literary skill and brave, useful honesty is what lifts the book above a simple illness narrative into something humane and important.

What are the weaknesses of An Unquiet Mind?

The caveats are modest and contextual. It’s a difficult read in places, depicting suicidal depression and a suicide attempt without flinching, content a vulnerable reader should approach with care. As a personal memoir of one well-resourced professional’s experience, it’s necessarily one perspective: the bipolar disorder of a Johns Hopkins professor with access to excellent care differs from many sufferers’ realities, so it shouldn’t be taken as representative of every experience of the illness.

And some readers want more clinical depth than a memoir provides, or more memoir than the clinical framing allows. Readers who want a textbook picked up the wrong book. These are matters of scope instead of flaws, and the book’s particular vantage point remains its great gift.

Is An Unquiet Mind worth reading?

It’s a landmark memoir of mental illness, valuable above all for its rare dual perspective, an author who’s both a sufferer of bipolar disorder and a world authority on it, able to render the felt reality of mania and depression while explaining them with clinical precision. It gets a high rating for that uniquely illuminating vantage, for beautiful, lyrical prose, and for brave honesty, especially about the difficult, common truth of resisting medication.

It’s a hard read in places, with depictions of suicidal depression that call for care, and is necessarily one well-resourced professional’s perspective instead of a universal one. I can’t think of a better account of manic-depressive illness from the inside, and she wrote it from both sides of the desk. (See also World Mental Health Day) It’s essential reading. Highly recommended.

Frequently Asked Questions