Latest
What You Have to Decide Before Anybody WritesWriting It Before You Need ItCross Training Covered Everything Except the Role That Mattered MostBehind the Book: You Don’t Own Anything AnymoreBehind the Book: The Woke VirusBehind the Book: Galactic InvasionWhat’s New at The Writing King: Week of November 8, 2026Alexander Zhidkov: Decision MakingJessi Szurek: Expand Your RangeYou Don’t Own Anything AnymoreThe Budget Decided How My Department Was ShapedWhy Your Competitor’s Book Is Working and Yours Would NotWhy Are These Guys Smiling? A Business Book That Became a Wrestling MemoirPangram Wants to Decide Who Gets PublishedWhat You Have Enough Material For Right NowWhen a Book Is the Wrong ToolThe Woke VirusGalactic InvasionChatGPT Turns Four: From a Free Research Preview to GPT-6What’s New at The Writing King: Week of November 1, 2026Diwali: The Festival of Lights and the Story Behind the LampsHow Much Water and Power Does Heavy AI Use Take? I Ran My Own NumbersBad Boys: Ride or Die (2024)Vesuvius Day: The Teenager Who Wrote Down Pompeii’s Last DayAnti-Communism Week: Remembering the Writers Communism SilencedVoyager 1 One Light-Day: Fifty Years to Travel One Day of LightVellum Added an Optional AI Feature. A Pile-On Killed It in a Day.Are AI Subscriptions Losing Money? The Gym Membership Math Says NoAI Terms Every Writer Should Know, and Why Each One MattersWorking While Sick: What 24/7 On Call Cost MeHe Banned AI From His Writing Group. His Own Cover Got Called AI Slop.Who Writes the Fake Fan Mail Authors Get? Inside the Scam CompoundsSMS Appointment RemindersJoe Rockey: Ghostwriting His BookDarrell Stern: Stop Being Invisible, Become UnmissableFree BooksHow to Turn Your Expertise Into a Book People Want to Read | The Expert MethodWhat’s New at The Writing King: Week of October 25, 2026Challenger Remembrance Day: The Engineer Who Wouldn’t SignJoel Salomon: The Truth About MoneyReddit Is Putting Up a Login Wall. Wikipedia Won’t Be Far Behind.Victoria Chemko: The Body Is the First TechnologySir Patrick Stewart: A TributeA Year in the Bank: ADHD, Face Blindness and the Freedom to Walk Out | The Impossible Puzzles Show, Episode 326A Yale Economist Says We Won’t Be Missed. He Forgot the Bread Line.Walter Koenig: A TributeAI Has Paid Off Outside Tech. Apollo Is Reading the Wrong Scoreboard.I Don’t Post Bad ARC Reviews. I Send the Author a Note.The Little Red Book of Stuff That Works!Your Kids Are Your Own Fault

Is the Remake Ever Any Good?

TL;DR: I own over 1,500 movies on disc, so the remake question matters to me. Hollywood reboots everything now, from Star Trek onward, and older versions can seem filled with qualities the new ones lack. But is that true, or is memory doing the flattering? This essay works through remakes that justified their existence and ones that never did.

I’m a movie buff, simple and sweet. I have over 1,500 movies in my DVD and BluRay collection, am a member of Flixster (primarily for their Ultraviolet service) and use an Amazon Fire TV because Amazon Prime has a good selection of free movies included with their service. These days it seems movies are somehow lacking in something. They’re missing some special qualities that older versions were filled with. Well, at least it seems that way sometimes. But is that really true?

The remake machine

One thing Hollywood is doing a lot these days is remaking old movies.

In the case of a series, such as Star Trek, they’ve coined the term “reboot” to indicate they’re reusing some of the basic concepts of the older episodes. In the case of Star Trek, the reboot dramatically changed the past history of hundreds and hundreds of episodes by destroying the planet Vulcan. Blowing up decades of history that fans loved, and getting a weaker movie in return, still galls me.

Of course studios often choose to remake movies and series because they’re a known quantity.

They can predict, or so they think, that the audience of the older shows will be attracted to the newer shows. That’s only true if the remake or reboot is in the same league as the original. When it isn’t, the studio has spent the goodwill of a movie people loved and handed back nothing, and that drives me up the wall.

The remakes I have judged

I’ve seen plenty of remakes and reboots over the years, and the films and series below are just the ones that come to mind, by no means a complete list.

The ones begging for a remake

Two movies that scream for a remake are Logan’s Run and Andromeda Strain. Both of these were great in their day, but time has left the originals far behind. I would love to see a quality remake of these two movies, made by people who respect what made them great in the first place. Give me that and I’ll be first in line.

Richard’s verdicts on remakes and reboots
Film or series Better version Richard’s verdict
The Italian Job Remake The remake had the magic the original was missing
The Great Escape Remake More chemistry than Stalag 17, fantastic casting
Star Trek Original Reboots lack originality, chemistry and sensible plots
Gone in 60 Seconds Original Remake watchable but nowhere near the chemistry
The Mechanic Original Original almost perfect; remake failed to reach it
King Kong Original Remake was a simple waste of film
Dune SciFi channel mini-series Catches the flavor of the book
Conan the Barbarian Both Both good in their own ways
Total Recall Remake Enjoyed it far more, though the original is a great

Leave your opinions of remakes that worked and those that didn’t in the comments. 🙂

Frequently Asked Questions

Are remakes ever better than the originals?
Occasionally, and the essay names names. Sometimes the remake has the same title and nothing else in common; sometimes a reboot justifies its existence. Memory flatters the originals more than we admit.
Why does Hollywood remake everything?
Because a known title is a smaller gamble than a new idea. Studios remake movies and reboot series to reuse audience recognition, from Star Trek onward.
Which movies deserve a remake?
A couple of classics are begging for one, Logan’s Run at the top of the list. Some stories were bigger than the technology available when they were first filmed.

0 comments

No comments yet. Yours can be the first.

Was this useful?

Leave a comment