Show, Don’t Tell

Show, don’t tell may be the single most-repeated piece of writing advice ever given, and also among the most misunderstood. Show, Don’t Tell by Sandra Gerth is a focused, compact craft book devoted entirely to demystifying that one important principle, what it means, when to apply it, when telling is in fact the better choice, and how to do both well. By zeroing in on a single high-impact skill that confounds so many developing writers, it does a useful job, and its narrow focus is its strength instead of a limitation.

Few pieces of advice make me grumpier than show, don’t tell as teachers usually hand it out. Writing teachers say it like a password and walk away, and they leave the poor writer staring at a draft with no idea what to change. That’s lazy teaching, and beginners pay for it with years of frustration. So it’s about time somebody sat down and wrote a whole book that explains the thing.

Demystifying the core principle

The book’s value is taking a piece of advice everyone has heard and explaining it, with clarity and practical technique.

Gerth covers what showing and telling really are. Why showing, through scene, action, sensory detail, and behavior, engages a reader more deeply than flatly stating information. And at the heart of it, how to convert weak telling into vivid showing.

People bring me books they wrote with AI that turned out to be crap, and they want them fixed. I’d bet a writer who’d absorbed this little book would have caught a good share of the trouble on their own, because a page that announces every feeling is the fastest way I know to make a draft go dead.

The concrete, example-driven approach is exactly what the slogan version lacks. A developing writer learns that they should show, and then learns how. That’s the difference between knowing the principle and being able to apply it.

This is the part I’d hand to every writer who’s ever been told to show more and felt scolded in a foreign language. Gerth’s examples teach it. You watch Gerth rebuild a flat sentence into a moment on the page, and the principle finally sticks.

Watch: Show, Don’t Tell. by Sandra Gerth, The Sojourning Writer

The smarter half: when to tell

The book’s most valuable contribution, and what separates it from the naive version of the advice, is its attention to when telling is the right choice. Show, don’t tell taken as an absolute rule produces bloated, slow prose that dramatizes trivial transitions and background that should simply be stated, and a sophisticated writer knows that telling has its place, for pacing, for summarizing the unimportant, for moving efficiently between scenes.

Writers who take the slogan as gospel end up with exhausting prose, where a character crossing a parking lot gets two pages of sensory detail. Somebody has to tell them they’re allowed to just say she drove home. Gerth does, and I’m grateful for it.

Gerth’s treatment of this balance, instead of preaching showing as an inviolable law, makes the book useful instead of just reinforcing a slogan, and it’s the mark of real craft understanding.

What are the weaknesses of Show, Don’t Tell?

The caveats are inherent to its nature. It’s a short, single-topic book, so it’s a focused supplement instead of a complete craft education, valuable for mastering this one principle and not pretending to be more. Its narrow scope also means it overlaps with the show-don’t-tell sections of broader craft books, so a writer who already owns broad guides may find it redundant, while one who wants dedicated, in-depth help on exactly this skill will value the focus.

And as with any single principle, it’s one tool among many a writer needs. These are the normal limits of a deliberately narrow, focused book instead of flaws.

Is Show, Don’t Tell worth reading?

It’s a clear, practical, useful little book on the most important and most misunderstood principle in fiction craft, valuable for its focus: it explains what show, don’t tell means and how to do it, and, smartest of all, when telling is the better choice. It gets a solid rating, held from higher only by the inherent limits of a short single-topic book that supplements instead of replaces a full craft education and overlaps with broader guides.

For a developing writer who keeps hearing the advice and can’t apply it, this is the quickest fix I know of, and I’d much sooner see them read it than sit through another workshop where someone scrawls show, don’t tell in a margin and moves on. A writer who already owns the big craft guides can safely skip it.

Frequently Asked Questions