TL;DR
9/10. A modern classic about the writing life that changes how you write, holding its place alongside Bird by Bird and On Writing. Its liberating idea of writing practice as a way past the paralyzing inner critic, and Goldberg’s intense, generous voice, make it a companion writers return to for decades. It falls just short of the top only because it’s deliberately not a how-to on craft mechanics.
Some writing books teach you how to plot or punctuate; Writing Down the Bones by Natalie Goldberg teaches you how to be a writer at all. First published in 1986 and beloved ever since, it’s a modern classic of the craft, routinely named alongside Anne Lamott’s Bird by Bird and Stephen King’s On Writing as one of the essential books about the writing life.
It draws on Goldberg’s years of Zen practice and presents writing as a discipline akin to meditation: writing practice. The focus is freeing the writer within, silencing the inner critic, and using writing as a path to seeing one’s life more clearly. It gets a high rating as a lasting work that changes how writers see their craft.
This is a book about the spirit and practice of writing, not a how-to on craft mechanics, and that’s why it’s lasted and why so many writers love it.
Writing as practice
The book’s central, liberating idea is writing practice: the discipline of writing freely and regularly, without stopping to judge, the way one might sit in meditation. Goldberg is a longtime Zen practitioner, and she brings that sensibility to writing.
Keep the hand moving. Write without censoring. Trust the first thoughts before the critical mind clamps down, treating writing as a practice backed, as she notes, by the same tradition that informs meditation.
The approach addresses the thing that paralyzes most writers. The inner critic declares everything garbage before it’s even on the page. Goldberg gives a way past that. Write first, judge later, and trust the process. For a blocked or self-doubting writer, it’s freeing.
Keep reading
Silencing the inner critic and freeing the writer within: Goldberg’s writing practice, in the wider fight against the block that doubt creates.
Watch: Natalie Goldberg Writing Down the Bones, Freeing the Writer Within, Books & Books
The voice and the spirit
Part of why the book endures is Goldberg’s own voice. It’s written in short, vivid chapters with witty, memorable titles. The intense, generous quality of it models the unselfconscious aliveness it advocates, so reading it’s both instruction and inspiration. She writes honestly about doubt, loneliness, and the fear every writer knows, and meets them not with rules but with encouragement, permission, and fierce gentleness, the sense of a wise, generous voice telling the reader to keep going.
That spirit, treating writing as a means of penetrating and celebrating one’s own life instead of a mere skill to master, makes the book feel less like a manual and more like a companion, and why writers return to it for the itch to write instead of for technique.
Keep reading
Writing as a way of understanding your own life: Goldberg’s spirit of writing as practice and self-discovery, in the deeper question of why we write.
What are the weaknesses of Writing Down the Bones?
The caveats are really just a matter of knowing what the book is and isn’t. It’s emphatically not a how-to on the mechanics of craft, it doesn’t teach plotting, character, structure, point of view, or how to get published, so a writer seeking those specific skills must look elsewhere; this book frees and sustains the writer, while other books teach the construction of finished work.
Its Zen-inflected, spiritual framing of writing as practice lands deeply with many but will strike some readers as too mystical or insufficiently practical, a matter of temperament. And its inspiration must be paired with actual craft and discipline to produce finished writing. These aren’t flaws but the nature of a book about the spirit instead of the mechanics of writing.
Is Writing Down the Bones worth reading?
It’s a modern classic about the writing life that changes how you write, taking its place alongside Bird by Bird and On Writing as essential reading. It gets a high rating for its liberating central idea, writing practice as a way past the inner critic that paralyzes most writers, and for Goldberg’s intense, generous, inspiring voice. That makes the book a companion writers return to for decades.
It falls just short of the very top only because of what it deliberately isn’t: not a how-to on craft mechanics, so it must be paired with books that teach construction, and its Zen-inflected spirit, freeing for many, won’t suit every temperament. For any writer struggling with doubt, block, or the deeper question of why they write, it’s close to essential. Highly recommended.
Explore the hub
The Psychology of Writing Hub: creativity, doubt, and the writing life, gathered in one place.
Frequently Asked Questions
Other Books From – Being an Author
About the author
