The Complete Guide to Writing Fantasy, Vol. 3

The Complete Guide to Writing Fantasy, Vol. 3: The Author’s Grimoire, edited by Valerie Griswold-Ford and Lai Zhao, is the volume that gets to the heart of what makes fantasy fantasy: magic. Where the earlier volumes covered fundamentals and advanced general craft, this installment focuses on magic systems, the rules, logic, and construction of the magic that sits at the center of so much of the genre.

I think it’s the one volume of the three with a clear reason to exist on its own. For a fantasy writer, a credible, well-built magic system is one of the defining challenges, and a volume dedicated to it addresses an important and distinctive genre problem. Judged as the specialized capstone it is, it does a useful job, with the series’ familiar multi-author characteristics.

The craft of magic systems

The volume’s value is its focused attention on building magic that works. A magic system done well has internal logic, consistent rules, costs and limits, and consequences that shape the world and the plot. Done poorly it becomes a convenient cheat that drains the tension out of a story. Magic that fixes whatever the plot needs fixed is cheap writing, and readers can smell it.

Devoting an entire volume to the construction of magic tackles one of the genre’s central craft problems head on.

It helps a writer think through how the magic functions, what it costs, and how its rules create both possibility and constraint. For a fantasy writer, this is exactly the kind of genre-specific guidance that a general craft book can’t provide. That gives the volume real distinct value.

The most distinctive volume

Of the three volumes, this one has the clearest claim to unique value because of its narrow, genre-defining focus. Where the foundation and advanced-craft volumes cover material that overlaps with general writing guides, magic-system design is a problem largely particular to fantasy and science fiction, so a dedicated treatment fills a real gap. The subtitle, The Author’s Grimoire, captures the spirit: a focused resource on the genre’s signature element, the thing that most distinguishes fantasy from other fiction.

Writers wrestling with how to make their magic credible and essential will find this is the volume of the series most likely to offer something they can’t easily find elsewhere.

What are the weaknesses of The Complete Guide to Writing Fantasy, Vol. 3?

The same honest notes apply. As the third volume in a series, it sits within the larger progression and is best understood as part of the set, though its specialized focus makes it more usable on its own than the others. The multi-author anthology format again yields variable quality and some unevenness across contributors. And a single volume on magic systems, while valuable, is one focused treatment of the topic; a writer serious about magic design will also want to study how the best fantasy novels build their systems.

These are the normal characteristics of a specialized volume in a multi-author series, not flaws.

Is The Complete Guide to Writing Fantasy, Vol. 3 worth reading?

It’s the most distinctive and most valuable volume of the series, a focused treatment of magic-system design, one of fantasy’s central and most genre-specific craft problems, that addresses something general writing guides don’t. It deserves a fair, solid rating, with its dedicated focus giving it the clearest claim to unique value among the three volumes, held from higher mainly by the multi-author format’s uneven quality and by the limits of a single volume on a deep topic.

It’s the most directly useful volume of the set for a fantasy writer wrestling with how to build credible, essential magic, and the one most worth seeking out on its own. If I were picking one volume from this series, it’d be this one. The uneven essays are all that kept it from scoring higher.

Frequently Asked Questions