Imposter Syndrome for Creatives: When Is It Too Much?

What is Imposter Syndrome?

Imposter syndrome is the nagging feeling that you’re not as skilled or capable as others believe. It’s common among writers, artists, and creators, who often feel they haven’t truly “earned” their success. Instead of recognizing their own talent, they feel like frauds waiting to be “found out.” These feelings, though uncomfortable, are surprisingly common in creative fields.

“The more people achieve, the more they can feel like frauds.” — Dr. Valerie Young, Psychologist and Expert on Imposter Syndrome

Try this: Next time you finish a creative project, take a moment to reflect on the steps it took to get there. Write down each part of your process to remind yourself of the effort and skill involved. Let yourself feel the pride of creating something from scratch.

A recent survey by The Journal of Behavioral Science found that nearly 70% of people experience imposter syndrome at some point in their lives. Writers, who constantly work in public view, may feel it even more acutely. Creativity is subjective, and external validation can be unpredictable—both factors that can exacerbate self-doubt.

For a deeper dive into overcoming self-doubt, consider The Artist’s Way by Julia Cameron, which offers exercises to reconnect with creativity and silence inner critics. Find it here on Amazon.

---

2. The Timeline of Imposter Syndrome

Most people experience the peak of imposter syndrome during major life transitions—like starting a new project, launching a novel, or stepping into the world of freelance. During these early stages, imposter syndrome can act as a motivator, pushing you to put in the extra effort and prove to yourself (and others) that you’re capable.

Timeline Insight: Studies suggest that imposter syndrome is often most intense in the first 3-6 months of a new endeavor. It’s a period of adjustment, filled with uncertainties. As you gain experience, the feelings generally start to ease.

One easy step is to set small, achievable goals during this adjustment phase. For example, if you’re writing a novel, set a goal to complete one chapter per week. This breaks down the project into manageable pieces, giving you little “wins” to celebrate along the way.

However, if these feelings last longer—six months, a year, or even more—they can affect mental health and productivity. Instead of fading, imposter syndrome becomes a persistent barrier, causing paralysis or avoidance. At this point, it’s no longer constructive self-doubt; it’s a cycle of fear that holds you back.

---

3. Signs Imposter Syndrome Might Be Holding You Back

Self-doubt is normal in moderation, but imposter syndrome can turn into a roadblock. Look for these common signs to see if imposter syndrome is affecting your creative output:

• Avoiding New Projects: If you constantly hesitate to start something new, fearing it won’t be good enough, you may be dealing with imposter syndrome.
• Perfectionism: Spending endless time editing and revising, thinking each line needs to be “just right.”
• Comparing with Peers: Constantly measuring your work against others’ and feeling “less than” every time.
• Downplaying Achievements: Not acknowledging your successes, seeing them as a “fluke” or “luck.”

Stat Insight: Research from a 2019 study published in Psychology Today found that 87% of creative professionals experience self-doubt or feelings of inadequacy.

Try this: Next time you finish a project, share it with someone you trust. Ask for specific feedback on what they like. Hearing genuine praise can help you shift focus from what you think is lacking to what truly works.

---

4. Why Writers and Creatives Are More Susceptible

Writers and creatives face unique challenges that make them more prone to imposter syndrome. Success in these fields isn’t easily measurable, meaning external validation can be rare. A businessperson can track success with numbers, but a writer might never fully know if their words truly resonate.

“You can’t be everything to everyone.” — Austin Kleon, Writer and Illustrator

The uncertainty and subjective feedback typical of creative work leave more room for doubt, making imposter syndrome a frequent companion. Writers, in particular, are often isolated in their work, relying on their own judgments.

One easy step is to keep a “praise file.” Anytime you receive positive feedback, save it. On tough days, read through these notes as reminders that your work is meaningful to others.

---

5. Why Imposter Syndrome Can Be Healthy

While imposter syndrome often feels negative, it has a healthy side, too. Self-doubt keeps us humble and prevents complacency, encouraging us to keep improving. By questioning our abilities, we may also identify gaps in our knowledge or skills, motivating us to learn more and refine our craft.

“Fear is always triggered by creativity because creativity asks you to enter into realms of uncertain outcome.” — Elizabeth Gilbert, Author of Big Magic

For more on managing self-doubt and embracing the unknown in creative work, you might explore Gilbert’s book Big Magic: Creative Living Beyond Fear, which you can find here on Amazon. When approached mindfully, imposter syndrome can fuel growth rather than hold you back.

Try this: Embrace your self-doubt by asking, “What can I learn from this?” Each time you feel unsure, try to identify one new skill or area of growth it’s pointing you toward.

---

6. Transforming Imposter Syndrome into a Tool for Growth

Imposter syndrome doesn’t have to paralyze you. In fact, many successful creatives use it as a signal that they’re pushing their boundaries, venturing into unknown territory, and challenging themselves.

“I have written eleven books, but each time I think, ‘Uh-oh, they’re going to find out now.’” — Maya Angelou, Poet and Author

One easy step is to remind yourself that every creative experience is an opportunity to learn. Keep a list of your achievements, no matter how small, and revisit it when you feel self-doubt creeping in.

Instead of letting imposter syndrome hold you back, see it as a reminder that you’re stepping out of your comfort zone. This feeling is often where real growth happens. Embrace it as a sign that you’re moving forward in your creative journey.

---

7. Building Confidence as a Writer and Creative

Building confidence as a creative doesn’t mean erasing imposter syndrome; it means learning to coexist with it. Start by celebrating your small wins and recognizing the value in every step of your creative process. Confidence doesn’t happen overnight, but with consistent effort, you’ll begin to see your own growth.

“Readers come to genres with expectations. Meeting those expectations, with a fresh twist, keeps them coming back.” — Jane Friedman, Publishing Expert

Taking time to understand your craft and hone your unique style is a great way to build confidence. The more you learn, the less intimidating imposter syndrome will feel. Connecting with other creatives, setting achievable goals, and reflecting on your accomplishments can also help you realize the worth of your work.

Try this: Each time you complete a piece of work, identify one skill you improved or one creative risk you took. Building confidence comes from appreciating these small but meaningful advancements.

---

8. When Imposter Syndrome Sticks Around: Seeking Help

Sometimes, imposter syndrome sticks around longer than expected, impacting mental health. If you’re feeling trapped in self-doubt, it may be time to reach out for support. A mentor or therapist can offer tools to manage these feelings constructively.

“Vulnerability is the birthplace of innovation, creativity, and change.” — Brené Brown, Author and Researcher

Seeking help doesn’t mean something is “wrong” with you; it’s an acknowledgment that imposter syndrome, like any persistent emotion, can benefit from an external perspective. Embracing vulnerability can allow you to create more freely, without the weight of constant self-doubt.

---

9. How to Keep Imposter Syndrome at Bay Long-Term

Even after learning to manage imposter syndrome, it can resurface from time to time. Here are a few strategies to keep self-doubt in check over the long term:

1. Set Clear Goals: Define what success means for you. Clarity can reduce feelings of inadequacy by giving you something concrete to strive for.
2. Document Your Progress: Keep a journal of your accomplishments, big or small. Revisiting this record can remind you of how far you’ve come, serving as evidence when self-doubt arises.
3. Practice Self-Compassion: Treat yourself with the same kindness you’d offer a friend. Remember, no one is perfect.
4. Reflect on Your Purpose: Regularly reconnect with why you create. Knowing your purpose helps put imposter syndrome into perspective.

Stat Insight: Studies have shown that self-compassion practices can reduce self-doubt by 40%, helping creatives build resilience and confidence over time.

Try this: At the end of each month, write down three things you did well and one thing you’d like to improve. This balanced reflection builds confidence without ignoring areas of growth.

---

Final Thoughts: Embrace Your Creative Journey

Imposter syndrome may be an inevitable part of the creative journey, but it doesn’t have to control you. Acknowledge it, manage it, and use it as fuel for growth. Every time you overcome self-doubt, you’re building resilience and adding depth to your craft. Remember, every creative has moments of insecurity—it’s how you choose to respond that shapes your success.

Ready to take the leap and grow as a creative? Reach out if you’d like guidance on overcoming self-doubt and embracing your potential.

Note: Please note, as an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases made through the book links provided in this article.