7 Powerful Insights into the Role of Political Correctness in Books Today

Should your story be politically correct

Unraveling the Intricacies of Political Correctness in Books – An Introduction

Make a Living as a Professional Self-Published AuthorWelcome to the fascinating exploration of political correctness in books. Our society thrives on diversity, leading to a myriad of perspectives on what’s right and wrong. These subjective moral compasses have evolved into what we now term “political correctness.” And where does this influence us the most? You guessed it – in the realm of literature.

In books, political correctness isn’t merely a trend; it’s almost a movement, dictating what is acceptable to pen down and what’s not. It’s akin to treading on thin ice – one wrong word could lead to a social media backlash or even a plunge in sales. This precarious situation begs the question, how does a writer navigate these turbid waters while staying true to their creative vision?

Let’s begin by looking at the concept of political correctness:

Agreeing with the idea that people should be careful to not use language or behave in a way that could offend a particular group of people – Merriam-Webster

This exploration into the implications of political correctness for authors isn’t about advocating for or against this phenomenon. Instead, it’s an objective look at how it shapes modern literature, possibly restricting authors, or pushing them to explore new narrative paths. After all, limitations can sometimes breed innovation.

How to be Politically Correct!

A sarcastic look at political correctness

Let’s dive in. From ‘Harry Potter’ to ‘To Kill a Mockingbird’, how have these classics navigated the waters of political correctness? Let’s not forget modern bestsellers like ‘The Hunger Games’. What role has political correctness played in shaping these narratives? Buckle up for a literary adventure!

Navigating the Waves of Political Correctness – The Writer’s Quandary

Venturing into the writing world presents challenges beyond just creating compelling narratives. The modern author must also address the implications of political correctness in their work, making the creative process more intricate than ever. A politically correct world assumes that guns equate to violence, discrediting alternatives and dismissing any debate as absurd.

Chris Rock - Gun Control

Chris Rock comedy skit about guns

Consider George R.R. Martin’s “Game of Thrones” series, where the portrayal of women and violence sparked heated debates. While some applauded Martin for his complex female characters, others criticized the frequent scenes of violence against these women. However, the question remains: Was this depiction essential to reflect the brutal world of Westeros, or could it have been more “politically correct”?

Political Correctness in BooksA writer’s work becomes a tightrope walk between telling an authentic story and avoiding any unintentional offense. Hence, navigating political correctness becomes an inevitable part of the writing process. It’s a constant balancing act that authors must perform to resonate with their readers while staying true to their story.

And it’s not just about avoiding offense. How political correctness shapes literature also extends to providing representation and challenging stereotypes. There’s a growing demand for diverse characters, leading authors to tread new ground while staying mindful of not appropriating cultures or perpetuating harmful stereotypes.

For instance, the ‘Twilight’ series by Stephenie Meyer has faced criticism for its depiction of the Quileute Native American tribe, highlighting the potential pitfalls of representation in literature. Therefore, in the era of political correctness, authors have an added responsibility to carry out thorough research and respect the cultures they represent in their work.

Feelings, Opinions and Dialogues – The Influence of Political Correctness

Feelings are paramount in the realm of political correctness, and any expression causing discomfort is shunned. But isn’t literature supposed to evoke strong emotions, stir debates, and challenge the status quo? Is there a middle ground for authors to strike a balance between being politically correct and staying authentic to their narrative?

Feelings, Opinions and Dialogues – The Influence of Political CorrectnessConsider J.K. Rowling, who has faced backlash for her controversial statements. Even though these statements weren’t part of her books, they influenced the readers’ perception of the “Harry Potter” series, demonstrating the far-reaching implications of political correctness.

In contrast, a book like Harper Lee’s “To Kill a Mockingbird” faced backlash for its racial themes at the time of its publication, yet it’s celebrated today for its frank portrayal of racial injustice. This showcases the changing perceptions of political correctness over time. What’s deemed offensive today might be lauded as groundbreaking in the future, posing another challenge for authors.

Moreover, there’s a thin line between being politically correct and whitewashing or oversimplifying complex issues. Can a narrative that doesn’t ruffle any feathers create a profound impact? Does striving for political correctness risk creating one-dimensional, “safe” narratives?

Take the example of Enid Blyton’s works. Her portrayals were a product of her times and have faced criticism in the modern context. The language and themes of her books, deemed non-inclusive and discriminatory today, reflect how perceptions of political correctness change over time.

The Pros and Cons of Political Correctness in Books – A Balanced Perspective

The impact of political correctness in books is as multi-faceted as the books themselves. Let’s take a closer look at the pros and cons that this cultural shift brings to the literary world, all while learning a thing or two from our favorite books.

Pros

The reasons to write a politically correct book include:

  1. Promotion of Equality and Respect: Political correctness promotes the use of language that respects all individuals and groups. The “Percy Jackson & The Olympians” series by Rick Riordan, for instance, has been lauded for its inclusion of diverse characters, from a main character with dyslexia and ADHD to another who is a wheelchair user. This representation promotes empathy and understanding among readers.
  2. Challenging Stereotypes: Books like “The Hate U Give” by Angie Thomas confront stereotypes head-on, encouraging readers to rethink their biases. Political correctness in books can facilitate such challenging dialogues, contributing to social progression.
  3. Creating Safer Spaces: A more politically correct narrative ensures that readers from all walks of life can find a safe and inclusive environment within the pages of a book. A great example is “George” by Alex Gino, a novel that sensitively portrays the experiences of a transgender child.
  4. Enhances Cultural Sensitivity: Political correctness in books can be instrumental in enhancing cultural sensitivity and understanding. Books like Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s “Americanah” present nuanced views of race, immigration, and identity, promoting empathy and cultural understanding among readers.
  5. Promotes Representation: Greater political correctness leads to more representation of marginalized groups. For instance, books like Angie Thomas’s “The Hate U Give” give voice to the African American community, something not often seen in mainstream literature.
  6. Encourages Respectful Dialogue: By encouraging politically correct language, books can play a pivotal role in promoting respectful dialogue in society. Authors, in adhering to this principle, can help dismantle offensive stereotypes and promote understanding.

Cons

Here are some reasons to ignore or tone down political correctness in books:

  1. Risk of Self-Censorship: The fear of backlash can lead writers to self-censor, possibly leading to less authentic storytelling. Take J.D. Salinger’s “The Catcher in the Rye”, a book that’s faced numerous bans due to its language and themes. If Salinger had self-censored, we might have lost an influential novel that speaks candidly about teenage angst and alienation.
  2. Possibility of Oversimplification: Striving for political correctness can lead to oversimplified narratives, which may fail to accurately portray complex societal issues. For example, many critics argue that Harper Lee’s “Go Set a Watchman” falls into this trap, presenting a simplified view of racism compared to its predecessor, “To Kill a Mockingbird.”
  3. Retrospective Criticism of Classics: Classics such as “Adventures of Huckleberry Finn” by Mark Twain face criticism for their use of racial slurs, despite these words being a reflection of the times when the books were written. The constant pressure of political correctness can thus, ironically, lead to a kind of cultural erasure, disregarding historical context.
  4. Possibility of ‘Overcorrection’: The focus on political correctness can sometimes lead to an ‘overcorrection,’ where authors may feel compelled to include diverse characters or themes not integral to the story, leading to tokenism or dilution of the narrative.
  5. Creates ‘Safe Spaces’ Limiting Exposure: Books are a means of exploring different perspectives and experiences. If all books adhered strictly to political correctness, readers could be deprived of the opportunity to encounter challenging or controversial viewpoints, limiting their intellectual growth.
  6. Threatens Freedom of Speech: Extreme political correctness could potentially threaten freedom of speech. The fear of backlash might deter authors from exploring certain themes or expressing certain viewpoints, thus impinging on their creative and expressive freedom.

Navigating the labyrinth of political correctness in books is indeed a daunting task. It demands a delicate balance, a fine tuning of sensitivity and boldness. In the end, the key is to respect diverse perspectives while being authentic to the narrative and its intent. The question remains: how do we collectively decide what’s deemed acceptable in our stories? After all, our books are the mirrors of our society.

Political Correctness and Creativity: Allies or Foes?

A salient question many ponder about political correctness in books is whether it restricts the creative freedom of authors. This relationship between artistic liberty and social responsibility is a delicate balancing act. Let’s delve deeper into this conundrum.

On one hand, the proponents of political correctness argue that it doesn’t limit creativity, but rather enriches it. They believe it pushes authors to think beyond stereotypes and familiar patterns, encouraging them to create more diverse and inclusive narratives. “The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time” by Mark Haddon, for example, provides an insightful look into the mind of a boy with autism. In doing so, it avoids stereotypes about autism, instead, offering a nuanced and empathetic portrayal. This book is a testament to how political correctness can inspire authors to explore lesser-told stories and perspectives, thus expanding their creative scope.

On the other hand, there are concerns that the pressure to be politically correct can stifle a writer’s voice. This argument holds that the fear of backlash or criticism can lead authors to self-censor, thereby compromising the authenticity of their work. A case in point is the controversy surrounding “American Dirt” by Jeanine Cummins. The author faced criticism for her portrayal of Mexican migrants, leading to a larger debate about who has the right to tell certain stories. The incident raised concerns about authors restricting their creativity to avoid such controversies.

Another aspect worth considering is the reinterpretation of classic works through the lens of political correctness. Classics like Joseph Conrad’s “Heart of Darkness” have come under scrutiny for their depiction of colonialism and racism. Some argue that this retrospective application of political correctness can lead to the erasure or misunderstanding of historical and literary contexts, thereby impeding a fuller understanding of these works.

In the case of satire, a genre that often employs exaggeration, sarcasm, and humor to critique society, political correctness can be seen as particularly restrictive. Books like “Catch-22” by Joseph Heller or “Animal Farm” by George Orwell employ politically incorrect themes and language to convey their messages. The stringent adherence to political correctness could risk sanitizing such narratives, thereby diluting their social commentary.

Navigating Political Correctness as a Ghostwriter

When working as a ghostwriter, the task of navigating political correctness in a book project requires careful communication with the client, a deep understanding of their voice and purpose, and the ability to strike a balance between authenticity and sensitivity. Let’s explore how ghostwriters handle this delicate dance.

  1. Effective Client Communication: The first step in addressing political correctness is to engage in open and transparent communication with the client. Understand their vision for the book, the intended audience, and any specific concerns they have regarding sensitive topics. By establishing clear lines of communication, you can ensure that both you and the client are on the same page throughout the writing process. For example, if you’re working on a memoir for a client who wants to share personal experiences related to race, it’s essential to have candid conversations about their intentions, ensuring that the narrative doesn’t inadvertently perpetuate stereotypes or offend readers.
  2. Understanding the Client’s Voice: As a ghostwriter, your role is to capture the client’s voice authentically. While maintaining political correctness, you must ensure that the words and perspectives align with the client’s beliefs and experiences. For instance, if you’re collaborating with a client who aims to challenge societal norms through their writing, you need to strike a balance between pushing boundaries and respecting the sensitivities of the readers. By immersing yourself in their perspective and understanding their intended impact, you can craft a narrative that achieves their objectives while adhering to ethical standards.
  3. Researching and Fact-Checking: Ghostwriters must conduct thorough research to support their writing, especially when addressing sensitive subjects. Accurate information and diverse perspectives play a vital role in avoiding potential pitfalls related to political correctness. For instance, if you’re writing a historical novel that explores the experiences of marginalized communities, extensive research into the historical context and consulting credible sources will help ensure that the narrative is respectful and accurate.
  4. Sensitivity to Cultural Context: Cultural context plays a crucial role in determining what is considered politically correct. A skilled ghostwriter is attuned to the nuances of different cultures, avoiding generalizations and stereotypes. For example, if you’re assisting an author with a multicultural romance novel, it’s important to respect and depict each culture accurately, without resorting to clichés or exoticizing characters.
  5. Editorial Collaboration and Feedback: Collaboration between the ghostwriter and the client, as well as with editors, is essential in addressing political correctness effectively. This collaborative process ensures that the book aligns with the client’s vision while also adhering to ethical standards. For instance, if an editor raises concerns about potential insensitivities or bias in the manuscript, it’s crucial to address those concerns constructively and make necessary revisions to maintain a politically correct and respectful narrative.

By employing these strategies, ghostwriters can navigate the intricacies of political correctness, striking a balance between client expectations, authenticity, and sensitivity, ultimately crafting a book that resonates with readers while adhering to ethical guidelines.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while political correctness in books can broaden the narrative landscape by promoting diversity and challenging stereotypes, it can potentially also impose on an author’s creative liberties. The trick is in striking the right balance – embracing sensitivity and inclusivity without compromising the authenticity and impact of the narrative. Authors are, after all, the sculptors of stories, chiseling narratives out of the marble of their imagination, and how much they let the hammer of political correctness shape their work is a choice that remains entirely their own.

In the end, it all comes down to the impact an author wants to make. Do they want to challenge their readers, make them uncomfortable, and force them to confront societal biases? Or do they choose to adhere strictly to the norms of political correctness, thereby ensuring their work is inclusive and non-offensive? Either way, it’s a tough decision to make. The concept of political correctness in books remains a controversial and complex issue, offering no easy answers.

Richard Lowe
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
4 Comments
newest
oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Catherine

Interesting read about political correctness. I learned a lot! I will be putting this to use in my writing.

Samantha Laycock

I absolutely love your list of pros. I think my favorite thing to do as a writer is to evoke emotion.

Jennifer Passmore

I definitely agree that a writer should write in the politically correct voice.

Karen

These are amazing suggestions, thank you so much…I know nothing about this subject and I definitely need to educate myself.