Writing Critique Groups: 10 Incredible Techniques for Using them to Enhance Your Writing Skills

Writing Critique Groups

Make a Living as a Professional Self-Published AuthorThe art of writing is a continuous journey of learning and growth, and one valuable tool to enhance this process is joining a writing critique group. These groups offer a collaborative and supportive environment where fellow writers review and critique each other’s work. They provide a forum to receive constructive feedback, improve your writing skills, and gain insights into various writing styles and techniques.

Writing critique groups are particularly beneficial for honing your craft without a significant monetary investment. They bring together individuals with a common passion for writing, offering a safe space to discuss, explore, and challenge each other’s work. You’ll receive genuine advice from peers who are equally invested in improving their skills, making these groups an enriching experience for all involved.

However, participating in a writing critique group isn’t just about receiving feedback; it’s also an opportunity to critique others’ work, which in turn improves your analytical skills and deepens your understanding of the craft. Giving and receiving critique in these groups will prepare you for dealing with editors and readers in the professional world, making you a stronger, more resilient writer.

The Functionality of Writing Critique Groups

For those wondering how to join writing critique groups online, it’s important to first understand how these groups operate. Digital platforms like Meetup.com have significantly simplified the search for suitable groups, making it easier than ever to find your perfect match. Usually, a writing critique group involves each member bringing a piece of their written work, be it a few pages or chapters, which is then constructively critiqued by the rest of the group. This feedback is invaluable in improving writing skills, as it provides fresh perspectives and highlights any blind spots in your writing.

Starting Your Own Writing Critique Group

If you can’t find a writing critique group that suits your needs, don’t despair! Starting a writing critique group is an exciting alternative. Tailoring a group to fit your styles, or formats that matter to you. The digital platform Meetup.com can be a convenient tool for organizing your group. Although there is a yearly fee, you’ll find locally interested members, saving you the marketing legwork.

For instance, my experience using Meetup to establish a Science Fiction themed writing critique group was notably straightforward. It took around six months to assemble a diverse group of roughly a dozen members. Once the group was consistently meeting, the necessity for the Meetup platform dwindled, and I was able to discontinue the paid service.

Here are some reasons you may want to start your own group.

  1. Customized Focus: You can create a group that aligns with your specific writing interests, whether it’s a particular genre, style, or subject matter.
  2. Flexible Meeting Times: When you are the one in charge, you can schedule meetings at times that are convenient for you and other interested writers.
  3. Control Over Group Size: Starting your own group allows you to determine the size of the group, allowing for a more intimate setting or a larger, more diverse group depending on your preference.
  4. Location Convenience: If there aren’t any existing groups in your local area, starting your own eliminates the need for long-distance travel.
  5. Creation of a Supportive Environment: As the group’s founder, you can create a supportive, respectful, and collaborative environment, fostering the kind of community that best helps you grow as a writer.
  6. Building Leadership Skills: Leading a group can be a great way to develop and refine your leadership and organizational skills, which are useful in any professional context.
  7. Encouragement of Regular Writing: The responsibility of managing a group and meeting regularly can act as a motivation to write consistently and meet your writing goals.
  8. Networking Opportunities: Creating your own group provides a platform for connecting with like-minded individuals who could turn out to be important professional contacts or even lifelong friends.

Starting your own writing critique group, therefore, can provide an array of benefits and opportunities, far beyond the simple prospect of receiving feedback on your writing.

Writing critique groups established in this way provide a unique and personalized touch to the feedback and critique process. They also allow you to connect with a community that aligns more closely with your writing interests.

Guidelines for Participating in Writing Critique Groups

How do yo critique writing?Participating in writing critique groups is not just about receiving critique; it’s also about giving it. Constructive criticism is key – it’s about providing honest feedback that can help the writer improve. It’s also crucial to remember to provide this criticism in a supportive, compassionate manner.

When providing critique, remember these golden rules: focus on the writing, not the writer; offer specific feedback, not vague or general comments; always pair critique with encouragement and positivity. Even if a piece of writing doesn’t resonate with you, it’s important to find positive elements to highlight before diving into areas that could use improvement.

To make the most of your experience in writing critique groups, consider following these seven guidelines:

  1. Give Specific Feedback: Aim to provide detailed and precise feedback, rather than general or vague suggestions. This will help the writer to make targeted improvements in their work.
  2. Maintain a Positive Attitude: Constructive criticism should be just that – constructive. While it’s important to point out areas for improvement, also highlight the strengths of the piece.
  3. Focus on Content, not Grammar: While spelling and grammar are important, the main focus of a critique should be on the content, including the plot, character development, and overall structure of the piece.
  4. Allow Everyone to Speak: Ensure that everyone in the group has an opportunity to provide feedback. This helps to create a diverse range of opinions and prevents any one person from dominating the conversation.
  5. Respect Confidentiality: If a member of the group is a ghostwriter, it’s crucial to respect the confidentiality of their work. Unauthorized sharing of ghostwritten material is a severe breach of professional ethics.
  6. Listen to Feedback: Receiving feedback can sometimes be as challenging as giving it. Take on board the constructive criticisms and suggestions offered by your peers, and resist the urge to defend your work. Remember, the goal is to improve.
  7. Stay Engaged: Regular attendance and active participation in the group can greatly enhance your experience. The more you invest in the group, the more you stand to gain.

These guidelines can help create a supportive and productive environment in writing critique groups, benefiting every member and improving everyone’s writing skills.

Avoiding Pitfalls in Writing Critique Groups

While writing critique groups can offer a wealth of benefits, they also come with their own set of challenges. For example, focusing too much on grammar and spelling can detract from the more crucial aspects such as style, plot, and character development. Also, it’s important to respect the writer’s feelings – avoid making any insulting remarks or unnecessary criticisms. Remember, everyone is there to learn and improve.

Recognizing these pitfalls can help you navigate your group more effectively and ensure a beneficial and rewarding experience. Here are six common pitfalls you might encounter:

  1. Inadequate Feedback: Sometimes, members may provide vague or nonspecific feedback, making it difficult to discern exactly what needs improvement. Constructive criticism should be specific, direct, and offer clear suggestions for improvement.
  2. Negativity Overload: While the purpose of a critique is to identify areas of improvement, an excess of negative comments can be disheartening. A healthy balance of positive and constructive feedback is crucial to keep the morale high and the critique productive.
  3. Overemphasis on Grammar and Spelling: While grammar and spelling are important, focusing too much on these aspects can sidetrack the critique from more substantial elements like plot, characters, or overall coherence.
  4. Dominating Personalities: Some members may dominate the conversation, leaving little room for others to contribute their feedback. This can lead to a skewed perspective and hinder the diversity of feedback.
  5. Confidentiality Breaches: Particularly relevant for ghostwriters, the unauthorized sharing of ghostwritten work in a critique group is a serious breach of trust and professional ethics.
  6. Resistance to Criticism: While giving feedback is a significant part of critique groups, receiving it constructively can be challenging. A defensive attitude can prevent a writer from benefiting from the critique.

How to Critique in Writing Critique Groups

Writing Critique Groups are a great way to improve your skillsWhen critiquing, it’s essential to remember that your role is to provide valuable insights that will help the writer improve their work. To do this effectively, you need to adopt a systematic approach.

For fiction pieces, consider the consistency of the characters, the coherence of background details, and the conciseness of the plot. Ask yourself, “Can I follow the plot? Can I envision the scene? Is the storyline predictable or clichéd?” For non-fiction pieces, the focus shifts slightly. You should ask, “Is the topic clear? Is it well-explained? Did I understand the material? Are technical terms explained clearly?”

Here are some of the ways you can effectively critique in writing critique groups:

  1. Begin with Positives: Start the critique by mentioning what you liked about the piece, highlighting any particular strengths or elements that stood out.
  2. Be Specific: Provide specific examples from the text to back up your comments. Vague generalizations are not as useful as detailed feedback.
  3. Focus on the Writing, Not the Writer: Make sure to distinguish between the work and the author. Your critique should be about the text, not personal attributes of the writer.
  4. Comment on the Craft: Analyze elements of the writing craft like plot, characters, setting, dialogue, pacing, and voice, providing constructive feedback on each.
  5. Address Larger Issues before Smaller Ones: It’s more beneficial to discuss overarching issues such as plot structure and character development before focusing on minor details like grammar or punctuation.
  6. Be Honest but Tactful: It’s important to tell the truth about how you perceived the text, but always frame your criticisms in a respectful and considerate manner.
  7. Suggest, Don’t Dictate: Remember that you are offering suggestions, not mandating changes. The author retains creative control and should decide which advice to follow.
  8. Acknowledge Subjectivity: Recognize that critique is largely subjective and your perspective is just one of many. Encourage diverse feedback from the group.
  9. Consider the Author’s Intent: Understand the author’s intended audience and genre. This will help frame your feedback within the context of the writer’s goals.
  10. Encourage and Inspire: Always end on a positive note, emphasizing the potential you see in the work and encouraging the writer to continue refining their craft.

These are some effective ways to provide feedback in a writing critique group, creating a supportive and helpful environment for all members. Always remember, your job isn’t to give the writer a hard time, but to help them improve their work. Keep your critique specific, concise, and respectful.

Taking Criticism in Writing Critique Groups

Participating in writing critique groups also means being on the receiving end of critiques. It’s crucial to remember that critiques are not personal attacks, but tools to help you improve your work.

Never argue with the person giving the critique. Accept what’s being said, and don’t feel the need to defend yourself. Remember, you don’t have to accept all the suggestions made, but do consider them seriously. Here are some tips:

  1. Stay Open-Minded: Keep an open mind when receiving feedback. Every perspective can provide valuable insights, even if it’s different from your own.
  2. Remember the Goal: The ultimate goal of writing critique groups is to help you improve as a writer. Critiques aren’t personal attacks, but rather tools for growth.
  3. Take Notes: During the critique session, jot down the feedback. This not only shows your respect for the person providing the critique but also helps you remember and process the advice later.
  4. Don’t Defend Immediately: It’s natural to want to defend your work, but try to resist this instinct during the critique session. Just listen and absorb the feedback; you’ll have time to reflect later.
  5. Ask for Clarification: If a piece of feedback isn’t clear to you, don’t hesitate to ask for clarification. A good understanding of the critique is essential for your improvement.
  6. Seek Specific Feedback: If you’re looking for feedback on a specific aspect of your writing, feel free to ask for it. It’s your work, and knowing what you want out of the critique can be highly beneficial.
  7. Be Grateful: Always express gratitude for the feedback you receive. Every critique is an opportunity to learn and grow as a writer.
  8. Reflect and Evaluate: Once the session is over, take time to reflect on the feedback you’ve received. Evaluate its applicability and decide which suggestions you want to implement in your writing.
  9. Remember It’s Your Story: While critiques are invaluable, remember that it’s your story. You have the final say in what changes you make.
  10. Keep Writing: Critiques can be tough, but don’t let them discourage you. Use them as motivation to keep writing and improving. The more you write, the better you’ll become.

Most importantly, have fun and see every critique as an opportunity to make your writing better. Writing critique groups are there to help you improve and grow as a writer.

A Note About Ghostwritten Works and Writing Critique Groups

Ghostwriters should bear in mind a crucial point regarding their participation in writing critique groups. Reading ghostwritten work in public, including in critique groups, is typically viewed as a serious breach of confidentiality. This is unless explicit permission has been granted by the client.

A ghostwriter who breaches confidentiality without your knowledge is not a professional. 11 Things Your Ghostwriter Doesn’t Want You to Know, Sam Tamlyn

It is highly unprofessional for a ghostwriter to read their ghostwritten material in public without prior consent. Trust and confidentiality are the pillars of the ghostwriting profession. Always respect your client’s privacy and keep their content confidential.

Conclusions

If you’re looking to improve your writing skills in a relaxed, supportive, and non-competitive environment, writing critique groups could be an excellent choice for you. The feedback and insights you’ll receive can greatly enhance your writing, and the relationships you’ll build with other writers can be inspiring and rewarding.

Regardless of your writing genre or level of expertise, there’s likely a writing critique group that’s a perfect fit for you. So why not take the plunge? Start exploring writing critique groups today, and see how they can help you grow as a writer.

Richard Lowe

9 thoughts on “Writing Critique Groups: 10 Incredible Techniques for Using them to Enhance Your Writing Skills

  1. Fransic verso Reply

    I agree with you, it’s important to focus on the content although grammar is important. Thank you for sharing!

  2. Ivan Carlo Jose Reply

    This is quite an interesting discovery for me. I’ve never really been part of a writing critique group but I’d love to join one to improve my writing.

  3. Marysa Reply

    I am always looking to improve my writing. This sounds like a great way to learn and gain some tips.

  4. Ntensibe Edgar Reply

    Hhhhmmm….I think I need to get myself in a group like this. At the moment, I am not in a good position to lead one but I would love to join one where we can grow one another, as writers!

  5. Ebony Reply

    I never knew writing critique groups existed, but I love this community concept! I am going to search on meetup.com like you suggested to learn more!

  6. Nyxie Reply

    My friend and I keep each other motivated without writing. We’re not afraid to tell each other the truth, brainstorm and help each other improve and it’s been an amazing experience for me!

  7. Ben Reply

    I love the idea of a writing critique group. I’m a writer – just for myself – but I find that I tend to become enamored with what I write to a degree that just isn’t realistic.

  8. Beth Reply

    I love this idea so much. We usually fall in love with what we’ve written, especially after we’ve gone over it a few times. It’s important to have others give it a read.

  9. Debbie Reply

    These are all really great points for participating in writing critique groups. I like that you highlighted how to be on the receiving end of the critique. Especially to never argue with the person giving the critique and accept what’s being said without needing to defend.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *