Rings of Power Critique: 7 Unseen Errors You Must Know

Rings of power critique

The One RingAmazon’s much-awaited epic fantasy series, “Rings of Power“, has sparked passionate discussions and polarized opinions among the audience. In this milieu, a critical Rings of Power critique becomes not just important, but almost necessary to grasp the intricacies of this high-budget production. This article will focus on the writing aspect of the series, primarily exploring the construction and execution of fight scenes, and contrast it with its legendary predecessor, “The Lord of the Rings” trilogy. The aim is not to compare these works but rather to offer an insightful analysis of what makes such scenes tick and why some of them might not have the desired impact.

Every new TV show aims to captivate its audience, taking them on a journey that transcends the realms of reality and sinks deep into the land of imagination. Producers and writers spin intricate webs of narratives, trying to create a world so fascinating that viewers find themselves engrossed and eagerly anticipating the next episode. Yet, there are instances when the results are not quite what were expected. The spinoff series of the legendary Lord of the Rings (LOTR) franchise, known as “Rings of Power,” serves as a prime example of such a scenario.

From the first episode itself, viewers have noted several discrepancies that have left them angry and upset in confusion and disappointment. The comparisons with its much-lauded predecessor are inevitable, making the flaws in Rings of Power all the more glaring. From power imbalances to the deviation from established character arcs, the issues are numerous, leading to the question: What went wrong with Rings of Power? Let’s see in this Rings of Power critique if we can figure that out.

The Showdown: Rings of Power vs Lord of the Rings

Examining character balance and abilities forms an integral part of our Rings of Power critique. “Rings of Power,” with its vast ensemble cast, provides ample opportunities to highlight individual character abilities in action. In a world populated by humans, elves, dwarves, and other mythical creatures, the series features several gripping fight sequences. These scenes play a critical role in unveiling the inherent skills of the characters, their combat strategies, and the degree of coordination they maintain under duress.

In a particularly significant scene, the Rings of Power presents a confrontation with a towering troll, providing an elaborate stage to showcase the abilities of both the creature and the characters battling against it. The troll, an embodiment of raw power and might, displays immense strength and a seeming invulnerability to ordinary attacks. The scene is spectacular in terms of visual grandeur and the sheer scale of the threat.

However, it falls short in showcasing a well-balanced fight. Galadriel’s overpowering abilities eclipse those of the other characters, diminishing their role in the scene. This overwhelming imbalance turns a potential team-driven confrontation into a largely one-sided spectacle, undermining the thrill of the battle.

Contrastingly, in the “Fellowship of the Ring,” the first installment of the “Lord of the Rings” series, the ensemble cast’s fight sequence against a cave troll in the Mines of Moria offers a starkly different depiction. Despite the troll’s formidable strength and size, the Fellowship doesn’t let this overpower the scene. Instead, they use this adversarial power to shine a light on their unique capabilities, thereby creating a more evenly balanced and engaging battle.

Each member of the Fellowship contributes to the fight in their distinct way, aligning with their established character traits and abilities. Aragorn and Boromir, the seasoned warriors, confront the troll head-on with swords and shields, demonstrating their courage and combat prowess. Legolas, the agile elf, opts for ranged attacks, using his archery skills to his advantage. Gimli, the stout dwarf, showcases his strength and resilience, while the hobbits, Frodo, Sam, Merry, and Pippin, exhibit their bravery and resourcefulness, despite their limited combat experience.

Such an approach imbues the scene with dynamism, with each character making vital contributions, establishing a shared responsibility for the battle’s outcome. The balance between the cave troll’s strength and the Fellowship’s combined efforts lends a sense of unpredictability to the scene, ensuring viewers remain engaged throughout.

Furthermore, this balance isn’t just limited to the physical prowess of the characters. It also extends to their emotional strengths, with the Fellowship showcasing remarkable courage and a willingness to risk their lives for their companions. This is especially evident when Frodo is seemingly mortally wounded by the troll, and his comrades rally to protect him, adding a layer of emotional depth to the scene that further amplifies its impact.

Through this comparison, we see how character balance and abilities, when effectively leveraged, can enhance the drama and tension of a fight scene. While spectacular visuals and grand spectacles can indeed be awe-inspiring, a well-balanced ensemble confrontation often creates a more compelling and immersive viewing experience. In this aspect of our Rings of Power critique, it is evident that a balance in character abilities is a crucial ingredient in crafting a memorable and engaging battle sequence.

The Misrepresentation of Galadriel

In our exploration of the Rings of Power critique, the character of Galadriel stands as a major point of contention. The character, who is revered for her wisdom and power, is represented quite differently in the Rings of Power series than in the original Lord of the Rings (LOTR) series. In Rings of Power, Galadriel emerges as an invincible warrior, single-handedly vanquishing an ice troll. While this portrayal underlines her strength, it seems at odds with the more nuanced characterization we have seen in the original series.

The depiction of Galadriel in the Rings of Power does not adhere to the consistent character representation we are familiar with from the LOTR series. While she is, without doubt, one of the most powerful beings in Middle Earth, she has never been presented as an invincible warrior. Instead, Galadriel’s character encompasses elements of wisdom, serenity, and the exercise of power with restraint. It’s true that she wields formidable might, but it is always portrayed with an inherent understanding of the perils of unbridled power, which seems to be absent in the Rings of Power series.

This alteration in character representation undermines the essence of teamwork and shared effort that runs like a central thread through the LOTR series. In LOTR, even the most powerful characters grapple with adversity, their struggles contributing to their character development and the larger narrative arc. But, presenting Galadriel as an unbeatable warrior in the Rings of Power takes away from this narrative continuity. It creates an underwhelming experience, lacking the thrill and engagement that audiences usually derive from witnessing characters overcome challenges through collective effort and personal growth.

Character continuity forms an essential aspect of any series, especially a franchise as iconic as LOTR, which has garnered a massive global fanbase over the years. The Galadriel fans have grown to admire is a complex, multi-faceted character – a blend of wisdom, strength, and a touch of vulnerability. This portrayal of Galadriel, who, in her wisdom and power, also struggles alongside her comrades, resonates with audiences, making her a more relatable and inspiring figure.

In addition, this problematic portrayal of Galadriel disrupts the inherent balance of power in the LOTR universe. In the Rings of Power critique, it’s essential to point out that this portrayal introduces a significant inconsistency, potentially threatening the storyline’s credibility. By stripping Galadriel of her vulnerability and the struggles that lent depth and complexity to her character in the LOTR series, the Rings of Power risks alienating a significant segment of its audience. It’s not just about a single character; it’s about the integrity of the world that has been carefully crafted and cherished by fans worldwide.

This apparent reimagining of Galadriel’s character in the Rings of Power presents an aspect of the series that could be seen as a disconnect from the established LOTR universe. Therefore, in the Rings of Power critique, it becomes increasingly evident that maintaining character continuity, particularly for beloved characters like Galadriel, is of paramount importance in ensuring audience engagement and preserving the integrity of the original series.

Power Levels and Consistency

One of the integral parts of creating a convincing fantasy universe, as is the case with the Lord of the Rings (LOTR) series, lies in establishing and maintaining a consistent level of power among its characters and creatures. The Rings of Power, however, seems to deviate from this crucial aspect. Within the Rings of Power critique, it’s necessary to point out that the balance of power levels, so carefully constructed in LOTR, seems to be missing. The Rings of Power presents scenarios where creatures meant to be formidable adversaries go down without much struggle, indicating a significant imbalance in power levels.

The inconsistency of power levels in the Rings of Power starkly contrasts with the meticulously crafted narrative of the LOTR universe. LOTR fans have grown accustomed to a particular hierarchy of power. The formidable creatures and the main characters, despite their distinct abilities, always possessed a balance in their power levels, which contributed significantly to the authenticity and believability of the narrative. However, when a troll, often portrayed as a potent adversary, is easily defeated in the Rings of Power, it disrupts this balance and raises questions regarding the storyline’s reliability.

For any spinoff series, retaining the original series’ established power levels is vital to offer a believable storyline and ensure that the fans remain invested. Altering these power levels, as seen in the Rings of Power, disrupts the immersive experience for the viewers, which could potentially lead to dissatisfaction. This distortion not only strays away from the narrative continuity but also threatens the compelling realism that the LOTR universe is known for.

More importantly, it’s not merely about preserving power levels but also demonstrating them realistically. Rings of Power introduces scenes where a creature famed for its strength and resilience, like a troll, is vanquished without much of a fight. Such a scenario is hard for a viewer, especially one well-versed in the LOTR lore, to accept. It creates an incongruity in the depiction of power that not only jeopardizes the credibility of the Rings of Power series but also undermines the rich lore that J.R.R. Tolkien painstakingly constructed.

This variance in power depiction in the Rings of Power can be seen as a disregard for Tolkien’s lore, leading to a disjointed narrative. A Rings of Power critique cannot overlook this discrepancy, as it forms a critical element that underpins the series’ credibility. Consistent power levels and their believable demonstration are essential in upholding the integrity of the fantasy universe that LOTR is. For Rings of Power to engage its audience and honor the legacy of the original series, it is imperative that it respects and adheres to the established hierarchy of power in the LOTR universe.

The Importance of Teamwork

One of the fundamental themes that resonate throughout the Lord of the Rings (LOTR) series is the significance of unity and teamwork. From the four hobbits journeying together to the brave and perilous Mordor, to the ensemble fighting off a cave troll in the Mines of Moria, every obstacle they faced was encountered and tackled together. In the Rings of Power, this emphasis on teamwork, unfortunately, is significantly diluted.

The deviation becomes particularly evident in the troll scene from the first episode. This moment, marked by a noticeable lack of the camaraderie spirit, diminishes not only the depth of character development but also the progression of the storyline, a point of contention for many in the Rings of Power critique.

In the LOTR series, teamwork was never merely about characters uniting to combat a shared enemy. It was more about how these characters grew together, learning from each other, complementing each other’s strengths and weaknesses, and forming a bond that deepens as they face adversities together. However, Rings of Power seems to miss this crucial element of character interaction and growth. This absence of camaraderie is a significant loss for the series, causing a rift between the familiar teamwork showcased in LOTR and the individualistic focus seen in the Rings of Power.

The importance of teamwork is further magnified when you consider what made the LOTR series so beloved among fans worldwide. The deep relationships between its characters, formed and forged through shared trials, tribulations, victories, and losses, all contributed to creating characters that were relatable, human, and cherished by the audience. Rings of Power, however, appears to have overlooked this vital aspect, choosing instead to focus on individual feats. This focus shift, however, feels somewhat shallow and lacks the depth and emotional resonance that the LOTR series is known for.

In the Rings of Power critique, the undermining of the teamwork theme is a striking deviation that fans of the LOTR series are finding hard to overlook. The depth of character development in LOTR, so beautifully portrayed through their combined struggles, created a sense of unity that engaged the audience on a deeper emotional level. This engagement is what made the LOTR series more than just a fantasy tale; it was a journey that the audience was part of.

By minimizing the importance of teamwork in the narrative, Rings of Power risks alienating a significant portion of its audience, who have grown to love the camaraderie and unity showcased in LOTR. This series, which is already under intense scrutiny due to its legacy, needs to acknowledge and respect the importance of teamwork to maintain continuity with the LOTR narrative and keep its audience invested. Only then can it hope to live up to the high expectations set by the LOTR series and offer a viewing experience that is not only enjoyable but also emotionally fulfilling.

Showcasing Real Strength and Bravery

The Lord of the Rings series, masterfully penned by J.R.R. Tolkien, has always stood out for its remarkable portrayal of strength, bravery, and resilience. Its characters encountered formidable challenges, yet they managed to stand their ground, face their fears, and persevere, resulting in a palpable depiction of bravery that resonated deeply with its audience. In the Rings of Power, however, the portrayal of these traits seems to be less profound and lacks the authenticity that LOTR fans have grown accustomed to, which is a concern often echoed in the Rings of Power critique.

Tolkien had a unique way of depicting bravery and strength in his characters. Strength was not about the ability to swing a sword, nor was bravery about merely defeating an enemy. It was about the determination to face fears head-on, the courage to continue despite insurmountable odds, and the strength to make sacrifices for the greater good. These qualities were intricately woven into the very fabric of the LOTR narrative, setting it apart and making it a timeless classic.

In Rings of Power, however, this nuanced portrayal of strength and bravery seems to be noticeably absent. The characters lack the depth that the LOTR characters were renowned for, and their feats often appear superficial and less impactful. They seem to overcome obstacles effortlessly, undermining the satisfaction derived from witnessing a character’s struggle, growth, and ultimate success. This absence of authenticity in character development and narrative progression is a crucial factor that turns the Rings of Power into a bad writing example, according to many fans.

This sense of authenticity in the depiction of strength and bravery is paramount to the audience’s emotional engagement. It allows the audience to connect with the characters on a deeper level, to empathize with their struggles, and to celebrate their victories. This connection is something that Rings of Power seems to lack. The characters appear invincible, facing little to no challenges in their paths. This lack of struggle takes away the opportunity for the characters to showcase their real strength and bravery, making them less relatable and less engaging for the audience.

Moreover, by removing the struggle, Rings of Power also removes an essential aspect of the hero’s journey. In LOTR, characters like Frodo and Sam faced immense trials and tribulations on their journey to Mordor. Their struggles, their doubts, and their moments of despair added depth to their characters, making their eventual victory all the more satisfying. In contrast, the Rings of Power characters’ effortless victories offer little emotional payoff, turning what could have been a compelling narrative into a less engaging series of events.

In the Rings of Power critique, this lack of authenticity in showcasing real strength and bravery is a significant misstep. The series misses the opportunity to create meaningful character development and emotional depth that were hallmarks of the LOTR series. For Rings of Power to meet the high standards set by LOTR and truly resonate with its audience, it needs to revisit these integral themes.

It must remember that true strength and bravery are not about easy victories but about the courage to face adversity and the resolve to fight on despite the odds. Only then can it hope to create characters as memorable and as beloved as those in the LOTR series.

Lessons Learned

The comparison between LOTR and Rings of Power offers us several important lessons:

  1. Consistency in Character Portrayal: Deviating from established character attributes can disrupt the storyline and confuse audiences.
  2. Power Balance: Maintaining a consistent power level helps create a believable fantasy universe.
  3. Teamwork: Highlighting the importance of unity and collective struggle adds depth to the narrative.
  4. Showcasing Real Strength and Bravery: Characters should showcase genuine strength, bravery, and resilience to win the audience’s hearts.
  5. Respect for Source Material: Spin-offs should respect the source material to maintain authenticity and credibility.

Each of these lessons can be applied not only to writing but to various aspects of creative endeavors. They serve as reminders of the intricate nuances involved in crafting a compelling narrative.

Conclusion of the Rings of Power Critique

Rings of Power, while it has had its share of supporters, has been widely criticized for its divergence from the established lore and narrative style of the LOTR series. From the misrepresentation of characters to the distortion of power levels, the apparent neglect for the importance of teamwork, and the superficial portrayal of bravery, Rings of Power has fallen short in several key areas that made LOTR a timeless classic.

These shortcomings, however, provide aspiring writers and creators with crucial lessons. Through understanding what went wrong in Rings of Power, we can appreciate the importance of maintaining character consistency, upholding power levels, emphasizing teamwork, and portraying bravery in its raw, unfiltered form. It reiterates the need for an authentic narrative that remains true to its source material and meets the expectations of its audience.

Every story is more than just a string of events. It is a living, breathing entity that resonates with its audience on an emotional level. The grandeur of the production, the scale of the storyline, or the visual appeal is secondary. What truly matters is the depth of the characters, the authenticity of their struggles, and the connection they form with the viewers.

The Rings of Power series serves as a potent reminder of these truths. It underscores the importance of staying true to the essence of storytelling, of bringing characters to life in a way that is believable, consistent, and emotionally resonant. As we move forward, it is essential to remember these lessons, to learn from the errors of Rings of Power, and to strive for authenticity, depth, and emotional connectivity in our narratives.

Because at the end of the day, what truly makes a story memorable are the moments that touch our hearts, the characters we see ourselves in, and the journey that leaves us a little changed, a little wiser, and a little more in love with the magic of storytelling.

Takeaways: The Rings of Power series serves as a potent reminder for all storytellers. It underscores the importance of staying true to character development, maintaining consistency in power levels, and the need for a believable and relatable depiction of bravery and strength. It highlights the critical role of teamwork in a narrative and the need to respect the source material when creating a spin-off. 📚💡

Richard Lowe
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
khoingn | The Broad Life

Wow, you truly put time to compare the rings here. I have seen LOTR but not the other. Your comparison really makes me want to watch Rings of Power.


I agree that Rings of Power has its flaws, particularly in its deviation from the established lore and narrative style of the LOTR series. However, it is important to note that these shortcomings provide valuable lessons for aspiring writers and creators. By understanding what went wrong in Rings of Power, we can appreciate the importance of maintaining character consistency, emphasizing teamwork, and portraying bravery in its raw form. Ultimately, storytelling is about creating authentic characters and emotional connections with the audience, and the Rings of Power series serves as a reminder of this truth. We must learn from its mistakes and strive for authenticity, depth, and emotional connectivity in our own narratives.


This is such an in-depth comparison. I have seen LOTR, and I think I saw a little bit of Rings of Power. Fascinating to read about the two!


I haven’t seen LOTR. My Sister in law has the DVD. I may ask to borrow. I’m way overdue.I haven’t heard of this one that is similar until now.

Barbie Rizman

Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this. I’ve always assumed it’s hard to discuss the Lord of the Rings series without mentioning the rings. I haven’t seen any of the series my self myself, so learning more about the power of the rings was helpful.


And so in every way that truly matters, The Rings Of Power fails from the writing to the acting to the presentation. I had fun watching the amazon series though.

Jennifer Prince

Oh wow! I didn’t realize it was out. I loved LOTR and would love to watch this as a follow up/similar genre. So interesting!


I have watched all of the LOTR movies and man were they great. I haven’t seen Rings of Power yet, I guess I need to check it out to see if there is any comparison. Great in-depth post!


That was quite the in-depth critique and comparison. I have watched some of the LOTR series but it has been so long that I’m not sure if I could compare it that well.